Benton RSS Feed

[Commentary] I am a veteran print guy and have treated Twitter as an offshoot of what I do the rest of the time. But I have never thought of it as a primary source of news until the events in Boston and, in particular, the manhunt that took place in Cambridge and Watertown a few days after the bombings. News has moved to the digital sphere, but how we manage that shift is still evolving, and the shape of future journalism still unclear. We have seen glimpses of what it might be, but that's what they are -- only glimpses.

The Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act (CISPA) is all but dead, again.

The controversial cybersecurity bill, which passed the House of Representatives last week, will almost certainly be shelved by the Senate, according to a representative of the Senate Commerce Committee. "We're not taking [CISPA] up," the committee representative said. "Staff and senators are divvying up the issues and the key provisions everyone agrees would need to be handled if we're going to strengthen cybersecurity. They'll be drafting separate bills." Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-WV), chairman of the committee, said the passage of cybersecurity legislation is "important," but said the bill's "privacy protections are insufficient." That, coupled with the fact that President Barack Obama has threatened to veto the bill, has even CISPA's staunchest opponents, such as the American Civil Liberties Union, ready to bury CISPA and focus on future legislation.

"I think it's dead for now," says Michelle Richardson, legislative council with the ACLU. "CISPA is too controversial, it's too expansive, it's just not the same sort of program contemplated by the Senate last year. We're pleased to hear the Senate will probably pick up where it left off last year."

Networks are crazy with rage over Aereo, a startup that streams live broadcast content. But even as broadcasters are busy filing lawsuits against Aereo, they're also inking Web-streaming deals of their own.

Broadcasters are finally tapping into a potentially massive market, with more eyeballs and more ads. But they were generally afraid to do it until the Aereo threat loomed, argued Bernstein Research analyst Todd Juenger. "History suggests the networks and distributors can come out on top," Juenger wrote, joking that if it works out, broadcasters should "perhaps send a big 'thank you' note to Aereo, for providing the kick in the pants to motivate the industry into action." Juenger draws parallels between Aereo and TiVo, which set off a similar firestorm in 1999: After TV industry titans filed a barrage of unsuccessful lawsuits against TiVo, cable and satellite providers promptly launched DVR services of their own and ended up overtaking the market. So far, the Aereo story is quite similar.

Time Warner Cable chairman and CEO Glenn Britt said Google Fiber, the 1 gigabit per second fiber-optic service launched by the search giant may have some of the glow from its parent, but in the end it isn’t offering anything that the MSO hasn’t successfully competed against for decades.

“What they’re doing is not any different than an overbuilder,” Britt said. “And we’ve had overbuilders for the last several decades in the business.” Time Warner Cable chief operating officer Rob Marcus noted that Google Fiber is currently in front of about 4,000 homes in Kansas City (2,000 of which are TWC customers) and so far, defections to the service are “de minimus.” He added that TWC’s subscribers in Kansas City and Austin represent about 2.5% of TWC’s total video and high-speed Internet customers. “Despite the glow, the products are essentially the same as others are offering,” Britt said. “The speeds for the last little bit of the plant are faster, but they connect to the same old Internet where most of the servers are actually slower. Who knows what their intentions are; they have to speak for themselves. I would question the economics of this and therefore their motives, but we’ll have to see what they do.”