August 2016

Code for America's Quest to Save the Brigades

Swelling numbers coupled with a temporary setback in fundraising have prompted the civic tech nonprofit Code for America (CfA) to begin restructuring its volunteer Brigade program. The undertaking, arguably one of the most pivotal the group has addressed since its start in 2009, aims to construct an operating model that can sustain its continued expansion. Since 2012, the San Francisco-based organization’s Brigade program has seen aggressive growth in its work to provide civic tech and open data tools to cities nationwide. CfA used part of a $1.5 million grant from Google to launch the Brigades, and in the five years that the program has existed, it’s increased its ranks from 19 chapters to now more than 80, with thousands of volunteers in cities throughout the US.

The program’s dramatic rise, however, has also pushed costs upward, and in 2015 a fundraising shortfall led CfA to freeze its financial support for Brigade operating expenses, events and meet-ups. CfA Founder and Executive Director Jennifer Pahlka said in a letter that this funding gap has since been closed by donors, but to ensure sustainability, the program must identify a new model for operations that isn’t as dependent on financial support from its parent organization.

Debate commission to Donald Trump: The dates are set

The Commission on Presidential Debates responded to Donald Trump and the Republican National Committee's complaints about the debate schedule with a message on July 31: The schedule is set. "The Commission on Presidential Debates (CPD) started working more than 18 months ago to identify religious and federal holidays, baseball league playoff games, NFL games, and other events in order to select the best nights for the 2016 debates," the commission said. "It is impossible to avoid all sporting events, and there have been nights on which debates and games occurred in most election cycles. A debate has never been rescheduled as a result."

Donald Trump and RNC officials have complained that two of the three scheduled presidential and one vice-presidential debates overlap with NFL games. The presidential debates are slated for Sept 26 at New York’s Hofstra University, Oct 9 at Washington University in St. Louis and Oct 19 at the University of Nevada-Las Vegas. The vice-presidential debate is set for Oct 4 at Longwood University in Virginia.

August 1, 2016 (Alan Perce)

BENTON'S COMMUNICATIONS-RELATED HEADLINES for MONDAY, AUGUST 1, 2016

Alan Perce, Former Chief Economist at the Federal Communications Commission

Today's Event: Spectrum Management Advisory Committee Meeting -- https://www.benton.org/node/244339


ELECTION 2016
    DNC 2016: Broadband Platform and Leaked E-mails
   FBI probes hacking of Democratic congressional group
   Gov Mike Pence: Trump campaign to discuss lifting media blacklist; RNC stays out of it
   Mike Pence might be the media’s new best friend [links to Washington Post]
   Donald Trump may have pulled out a surprise victory (in television ratings) [links to Washington Post]
   TV ratings: 28 million watch final night of DNC [links to Politico]
   Republican convention narrowly beats Dem gathering in Facebook interest [links to Hill, The]
   How Donald Trump Beat Reddit [links to Atlantic, The]
   Democrats want reform — but court big money in the meantime [links to Center for Public Integrity]
   Apple CEO Tim Cook is hosting a fundraiser for Hillary Clinton [links to Verge, The]

SECURITY
   Crovitz: The DNC leaks were another Russian victory as the U.S. fails to fight back [links to Wall Street Journal editorial]
   Rep Jim Langevin: After DNC hack, US must better prepare for information warfare [links to Christian Science Monitor]
   Op-ed: How to make democracy harder to hack [links to Christian Science Monitor]
   The secret linguistics clues researchers used to link DNC hack to Russia [links to Christian Science Monitor]

INTERNET/BROADBAND
   Big Telecom Wants a DC Circuit Net Neutrality Review. Here’s Why That’s Unlikely
   FCC Chairman Wheeler Statement On Industry Petitions To Rehear Open Internet Court Case - press release
   Public Knowledge Responds to Trade Group Attempts to Reverse Net Neutrality Ruling - press release [links to Benton summary]
   Cable and Phone Lobby’s Desperate Legal Moves Are Just ‘Sour Grapes’ About Net Neutrality Ruling - Free Press press release [links to Benton summary]
   Madison (WI) tests Public-Private Partnerships to Reduce Its Digital Divide - press release
   AT&T raises usage allowance on U-verse, GigaPower fiber broadband [links to Benton summary]
   The growth in 'underconnected' Californians should alarm us - analysis

EDUCATION
   How beneficial are 'one-to-one' laptop programs in schools? - op-ed

TELEVISION
   Sinclair Settles FCC Investigation into Retransmission Negotiation Violations for $9.5 Million - press release
   Layer3 TV to Launch in Chicago Soon, Backed by Altice and John Paulson [links to Benton summary]
   Has the reality genre jumped the shark? [links to Guardian, The]

GOVERNMENT & COMMUNICATIONS
   Donald Trump’s wish for hacking powers sets up disaster scenario Snowden feared - CJR op-ed
   Snowden and WikiLeaks Clash Over How to Disclose Secrets [links to Benton summary]

WIRELESS/SPECTRUM
   Telecoms Consider Fee Hikes, as Fierce Price War Plays Out [links to Benton summary]
   US mobile switching at a record low as consumers put off upgrades [links to Benton summary]
   Columbus (OH) Outfits Buses with Wi-Fi [links to Benton summary]
   Annual Conference Will Explore Spectrum Forensics - NTIA press release [links to Benton summary]

CONTENT
   Instagram is building the anti-harassment tools Twitter won't [links to Verge, The]
   Has your child bought a Facebook app without asking? You can get a refund [links to Benton summary]
   Why free Wi-Fi kiosks in NYC can't stop people from watching adult content in public [links to CNNMoney]

OWNERSHIP
   Yahoo and the Online Universe According to Verizon [links to Benton summary]
   National Association of Broadcasters: FCC Maintaining Crossownership Ban Is Inexplicable [links to Benton summary

TELECOM
   Judge: First Amendment Protects Political Robocalls [links to Wall Street Journal]

DIVERSITY
   How Vector Space Mathematics Reveals the Hidden Sexism in Language [links to Technology Review]

POLICYMAKERS
   President Obama to Leave the White House a Nerdier Place Than He Found It [links to Benton summary]
   Alan Perce, Former Chief Economist at the Federal Communications Commission
   Paula Kerger of PBS: Find the Courage to Take a Terrifying Leap [links to New York Times]

COMPANY NEWS
   Facebook could owe $5 billion in back taxes [links to Benton summary]
   Google is letting you inside its moonshot lab to justify its existence [links to Washington Post]
   What’s Next at Fox News, With Ailes Out and Murdoch In? [links to New York Times]
   Facebook, Google surge on mobile revenue; Cloud businesses boost Amazon, Microsoft [links to Wall Street Journal]

back to top

ELECTION 2016

DNC 2016: BROADBAND PLATFORM AND LEAKED E-MAILS
[SOURCE: Benton Foundation, AUTHOR: Robbie McBeath]
This week, Hillary Clinton and the Democratic Party swept into Philadelphia (PA) for the 2016 Democratic National Convention. The party unveiled its platform, which contains a plan for universal broadband, a commitment to an open Internet both here and abroad, and -- ironically, it turns out -- cybersecurity promises. Just prior to the convention, Wikileaks released e-mails from top Democratic National Committee staffers, resulting in the resignation of party Chairwoman Rep Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-FL). The shadow cast by the leaks was the backdrop to a convention that featured Clinton making history as the first woman nominated by a major political party in the U.S. to be President. Let’s unpack some of the most important parts of DNC 2016.
benton.org/headlines/dnc-2016-broadband-platform-and-leaked-e-mails | Benton Foundation
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top


FBI PROBES HACKING OF DEMOCRATIC CONGRESSIONAL GROUP
[SOURCE: Reuters, AUTHOR: Joseph Men, Dustin Volz, Mark Hosenball]
The FBI is investigating a cyberattack against another US Democratic Party group, which may be related to an earlier hack against the Democratic National Committee, apparently. The previously unreported incident at the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, or DCCC, and its potential ties to Russian hackers are likely to heighten accusations, so far unproven, that Moscow is trying to meddle in the US presidential election campaign to help Republican nominee Donald Trump. The Kremlin denied involvement in the DCCC cyber-attack. Hacking of the party's e-mails caused discord among Democrats at the party's convention in Philadelphia (PA) to nominate Hillary Clinton as its presidential candidate. The newly disclosed breach at the DCCC may have been intended to gather information about donors, rather than to steal money, apparently. It was not clear what data was exposed, although donors typically submit a variety of personal information including names, e-mail addresses and credit card details when making a contribution. It was also unclear if stolen information was used to hack into other systems. The DCCC raises money for Democrats running for seats in the U.S. House of Representatives. The intrusion at the group could have begun as recently as June.
benton.org/headlines/fbi-probes-hacking-democratic-congressional-group | Reuters | The Hill
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top


TRUMP’S BLACKLIST
[SOURCE: Politico, AUTHOR: Hadas Gold]
Republican Vice Presidential nominee Mike Pence (R-IN) said the Trump campaign is having conversations about lifting the blacklist it has applied to certain media outlets. Speaking to radio host Hugh Hewitt, Gov Pence defended his own history of dealing with the news media, saying he authored legislation while in Congress to help protect journalists’ confidential sources. “We’re going to have those conversations internally and I fully expect in the next 100 days we’re going to continue to be available to the media, whether they’re fair or unfair," Gov Pence said. The Trump campaign has blacklisted certain outlets, including Politico, The Washington Post, The Huffington Post and others, from attending his events because of what he considers unfair coverage. CNN’s Chris Cuomo said he is blacklisted from the Trump campaign “because of how we conduct our interviews.” Trump may be the Republican nominee, but the Republican National Committee refuses to get involved or even comment on Trump’s treatment of the news media, instead diverting all questions to the campaign.
benton.org/headlines/gov-mike-pence-trump-campaign-discuss-lifting-media-blacklist-rnc-stays-out-it | Politico | Politico- RNC
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top

INTERNET/BROADBAND

BIG TELECOM WANTS A DC CIRCUIT NET NEUTRALITY REVIEW. HERE'S WHY THAT'S UNLIKELY
[SOURCE: Vice, AUTHOR: Sam Gustin]
The nation’s largest cable and telecommunication industry trade groups on July 29 asked a federal court for a rare “en banc” review of June’s decision upholding US rules protecting network neutrality, the principle that all content on the Internet should be equally accessible to consumers. “The likelihood that the full DC Circuit would agree to rehear the case, much less reverse the panel’s decision, is extremely remote,” Andrew Schwartzman, Benton Senior Counselor at the Public Interest Communications Law Project at Georgetown University Law Center's Institute for Public Representation, wrote in a recent article. “The DC Circuit typically agrees to rehear a case only a few times each year, at most, usually where there is a sharp split on an important issue on which other circuits have taken a different stance,” Schwartzman wrote. “This case doesn’t meet those criteria and thus starts out as a particularly poor candidate for rehearing.” There is no fixed timeline for the DC Circuit to respond to the broadband industry’s petitions. Federal courts typically respond to en banc requests within a few weeks, but given the fact that August is a slow month for the federal bench, the court could wait until September or even October to respond, according to Schwartzman.
benton.org/headlines/big-telecom-wants-dc-circuit-net-neutrality-review-heres-why-thats-unlikely | Vice | Benton article
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top


WHEELER STATEMENT
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission, AUTHOR: FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler]
Industry groups have filed petitions asking for an en banc rehearing of the DC Circuit Court’s decision to uphold the FCC’s Open Internet rules. FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler said, ““It comes as no surprise that the big dogs have challenged the three-judge panel’s decision. We are confident that the full court will agree with the panel’s affirmation of the FCC’s clear authority to enact its strong Open Internet rules, the reasoned decision-making upon which they are based, and the adequacy of the record from which they were developed.”
benton.org/headlines/fcc-chairman-wheeler-statement-industry-petitions-rehear-open-internet-court-case | Federal Communications Commission
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top


MADISON TESTS PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS TO REDUCE ITS DIGITAL DIVIDE
[SOURCE: Coalition for Local Internet Choice, AUTHOR: ]
Over the next two years, the City of Madison (WI) will invest $500,000 in general obligation capital funds to experiment with a creative public private partnership to bring fiber-to-the-building services to more than 1,000 underserved families. Madison has been attacking the community’s digital divide from an anchor institution angle for years and using public-private partnerships to get there. "[Broadband Technology Opportunities Program] layed the framework,” said Richard Beadles, Technical Services Manager for the city. Mayor Paul Soglin made digital equity a priority five years ago, and the City won a $10 million BTOP grant to build a fiber middle mile network to connect its municipal buildings and libraries, higher education, schools and other municipalities in the area. The new Metropolitan Unified Fiber Network (MUFN) was born. In exchange for using part of the network for commercial services, a company called Wisconsin Independent Network (WIN) connected all the schools and the 14 community centers to fiber and gave them free 100 Mbps symmetrical service. A non-profit called DANEnet managed the network and data communications for those community centers. Then two years ago, the City budgeted and fiber connected another 10 cultural centers. WIN was required to provide free Internet service to the centers by contract and worked with ResTech Services to provide 100 Mbps service at no cost.
benton.org/headlines/madison-wi-tests-public-private-partnerships-reduce-its-digital-divide | Coalition for Local Internet Choice
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top


CALIFORNIA’S UNDERCONNECTED
[SOURCE: San Jose Mercury News, AUTHOR: Michelle Quinn]
[Commentary] At first glance, the latest data on California's digital divide looks like amazingly good news. A whopping 84 percent of Californians now have access to broadband internet at home, up 9 percentage points since 2014, according to a new Field Poll. At that rate, the digital divide -- the gulf between the information haves and have nots -- could be wiped out in less than three years. But most of those gains have come from increased smartphone use. In the past year alone, there's been a near doubling -- from 8 percent to 14 percent -- of state residents now online because of smartphones. Meanwhile, the percentage of Californians connecting to the internet via a laptop or a desktop has remained flat for several years. It’s alarming that outside of smartphones, the same old digital divide persists and keeps minorities, the poor and many seniors from reaping the riches of the information age. The digital divide should be a call to Silicon Valley technologists, who are working on the next generation of smartphones and apps: Make smartphones even more useful. What else can you do? The digital divide is not about just about laptop brands and broadband speeds. It's about equality -- who gets access to information and opportunity that others take for granted. Those who are being left behind are doing their best to catch up by using smartphones. We shouldn't make it so hard.
benton.org/headlines/growth-underconnected-californians-should-alarm-us | San Jose Mercury News
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top

EDUCATION

TECH AND SCHOOLS
[SOURCE: Christian Science Monitor, AUTHOR: Binbin Zheng, Mark Warschauer,]
[Commentary] An international study by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development found no positive evidence of impact of educational technology on student performance. It did not find any significant improvement in reading, math or science in countries that heavily invested in technology to improve student achievement. In fact, the report found that technology perhaps even widened the achievement gaps. Does this mean we should abandon attempts to integrate technology in schools? We are researchers of technology and learning in K-12 environments, and our research suggests this would be shortsighted.
[Binbin Zheng is an Assistant Professor, Michigan State University. Mark Warschauer is Professor of Education and Informatics, University of California, Irvine.]
benton.org/headlines/how-beneficial-are-one-one-laptop-programs-schools | Christian Science Monitor
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top

TELEVISION

SINCLAIR SETTLES FCC INVESTIGATION INTO RETRANS NEGOTIATION VIOLATIONS
[SOURCE: Federal Communications Commission, AUTHOR: Press release]
The Federal Communications Commission announced that Sinclair Broadcast Group will pay $9,495,000 to resolve a number of Media Bureau investigations, including the Bureau’s investigation of allegations that Sinclair violated its obligation to negotiate for retransmission consent in good faith. The Commission’s retransmission consent rules, as mandated by Congress, forbid a broadcaster to negotiate jointly for one of its stations and for another station in the same market that it does not control. In its investigation, the Media Bureau found that, over the course of seven months, Sinclair negotiated retransmission consent on behalf of dozens stations that it did not control at the same time that it was negotiating for its own stations in the same markets. In addition to agreeing to pay $9,495,000, Sinclair has agreed to implement a compliance plan aimed at ensuring no similar violations in the future. This action is the first of its kind to enforce the Commission’s long-standing retransmission consent rules. The settlement also resolves a number of other issues that had been pending for Sinclair-owned stations, and the Bureau has agreed to grant all pending Sinclair renewal applications as part of the settlement terms.
benton.org/headlines/sinclair-settles-fcc-investigation-retransmission-negotiation-violations-95-million | Federal Communications Commission | Broadcasting&Cable
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top

GOVERNMENT & COMMUNICATIONS

TRUMP'S WISH FOR HACKING POWER SETS UP DISASTER SCENARIO SNOWDEN FEARED
[SOURCE: Columbia Journalism Review, AUTHOR: Trevor Timm]
[Commentary] Donald Trump shocked a lot of people when he suggested (maybe sarcastically, maybe not?) that he hopes Russia is hacking the e-mails of Hillary Clinton so they can find the ones she deleted from her private server. There was another phrase, however, he used later in the day that didn’t get the same attention yet was perhaps more disturbing. While claiming he didn’t have anything to do with the hacking of his political enemies at the Democratic National Committee, he said: “I wish I had that power, man, that would be power.” This really gets at the crux of why civil libertarians have been arguing for years that the National Security Agency has to be significantly curtailed. Even if you believe that the Obama Administration is 100 percent trustworthy and no one at the NSA under his watch has abused the agency’s vast spying powers (which, by the way, evidence refutes), the real danger is the infrastructure in place that would allow some future leader to wreak havoc. A future leader just like Donald Trump. In fact, this was the exact scenario that Edward Snowden warned about when he first went public in 2013.
[Trevor Timm is the executive director of Freedom of the Press Foundation.]
benton.org/headlines/donald-trumps-wish-hacking-powers-sets-disaster-scenario-snowden-feared | Columbia Journalism Review
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top

POLICYMAKERS

ALAN PERCE
[SOURCE: Washington Post, AUTHOR: ]
Dr Alan Perce died at the family home in Lexington (VA) on July 10, 2016. Perce was born November 10, 1937, in Manchester, England. He studied at the London School of Economics and Indiana University, where he received a Doctor of Philosophy in Business. Perce was one of the prime architects of the information era, coming to Washington (DC) in 1970 as Chief Economist at the Federal Communications Commission, and later working for the House Subcommittee on Communications, and at the White House, Office of Telecommunications. Dr. Pearce founded Information Age Economics, providing consulting services to high tech companies. Before coming to the US, Perce was a newspaper reporter, and worked as Foreign Desk Editor for Independent Television News (ITN). A Memorial Service will be held September 10.
benton.org/headlines/alan-perce-former-chief-economist-federal-communications-commission | Washington Post
Share: Twitter | Facebook
back to top

The growth in 'underconnected' Californians should alarm us

[Commentary] At first glance, the latest data on California's digital divide looks like amazingly good news. A whopping 84 percent of Californians now have access to broadband internet at home, up 9 percentage points since 2014, according to a new Field Poll. At that rate, the digital divide -- the gulf between the information haves and have nots -- could be wiped out in less than three years. But most of those gains have come from increased smartphone use. In the past year alone, there's been a near doubling -- from 8 percent to 14 percent -- of state residents now online because of smartphones. Meanwhile, the percentage of Californians connecting to the internet via a laptop or a desktop has remained flat for several years.

It’s alarming that outside of smartphones, the same old digital divide persists and keeps minorities, the poor and many seniors from reaping the riches of the information age. The digital divide should be a call to Silicon Valley technologists, who are working on the next generation of smartphones and apps: Make smartphones even more useful. What else can you do? The digital divide is not about just about laptop brands and broadband speeds. It's about equality -- who gets access to information and opportunity that others take for granted. Those who are being left behind are doing their best to catch up by using smartphones. We shouldn't make it so hard.