May 2010

WiFi a Serious Technology in the Broadband Mix?

[Commentary] Money may or may not be the root of all evil, but it is certainly the tail threatening to wag the dog for many communities' broadband planning teams. At the California Emerging Technology Fund's Rural Connections workshop last week, a number of people representing communities expressed concern they can't move broadband forward until they can find money. Make no mistake; you can't build a network without a passel of dead presidents to fund it. But you can mitigate the money hurdles you face, particularly if you don't put extra ones in your way.

When facts distort broadband reality, bad things happen

[Commentary] The challenge for everyone fighting for better broadband is that the constant repetition of facts from supposed "credible third parties" can sell people on positions counter to their best interests if we're not vigilant and diligent.

Our task is not separating fact from fiction, but separating reality from stated fact and the context of that fact's use. One industry response to the argument that there isn't competitive broadband in much of the U.S. is, "We have the lowest concentration and Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) among the 26 Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD) countries monitored by Bank of America Merrill Lynch, including the lowest concentration among the top two providers."

Having just co-authored a report on the state of broadband competition in the U.S., I can tell you with certainty there are several ways to factually support a positive or a negative view of competition. However, you can't escape the reality of market share, particularly when you take data directly from millions of customers to determine who uses which providers, as we did. In many states, statewide market share reveals near or actual duopolies, most often with one wireless and one cable provider as the un-dynamic duo. When you look at data at the county and city level, the reality for many re-defines bleak.

CBO Scores Grid Reliability and Infrastructure Defense Act

The Congressional Budget Office has completed a cost estimate for the Grid Reliability and Infrastructure Defense Act (HR 5026), a bill that would amend existing law regarding the regulation of electric power transmission facilities.

Under current law, most of the standards governing the reliability of the bulk-power system are issued by the Electric Reliability Organization (ERO), subject to approval and enforcement by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). This bill would set deadlines for FERC to issue standards regarding the security of computer networks used in electric power transmission (known as cybersecurity) and other risks to the electric power transmission grid, subject to certain conditions. In addition, both FERC and ERO would be directed to ensure that utilities maintain adequate supplies of large electrical transformers and implement measures to protect their systems against geomagnetic storms (incidents involving solar radiation). Other provisions would authorize a new technical assistance program related to grid security and establish terms and procedures for responding to emergencies, protecting information, and identifying strategically important electric facilities.

CBO estimates that implementing this bill would increase net direct spending by about $5 million over the 2011-2015 period and $40 million over the 2011-2020 period. Implementing the bill would increase discretionary spending by $219 million over the 2011-2015 period. CBO estimates that enacting this bill would not affect revenues.

Smart grid privacy rules may be blown opportunity for science

Over the past several years, social scientists have had a field day studying the vast libraries of digital records that are produced as a happy byproduct of society's increased use of electronic systems.

Anonymized cell phone records have given us new perspectives on human mobility. Logs from virtual worlds like Everquest and World of Warcraft have powered studies in fields from behavioral psychology to epidemiology. Today's issue of Science contains a stark warning that researchers could miss out on what may eventually be an even greater opportunity for access to this sort of data: the smart grid. Combined, the US and Europe plan to install nearly 300 million smart grid devices within the next decade. Depending on the precise device used, these will monitor electricity use in homes and offices at time spans of considerably less than an hour and in some cases as short as every minute. The smartest of these devices can include data about specific appliances in use; by tracking things like current, phase, and frequency. Even the dumber ones can provide information about what's going on when it comes to power use. That sort of data presents both an incredible opportunity and an incredible risk. It can provide a great perspective on what's going on in different areas of a nation or the world, and associate it with all sorts of interesting variables: economic activity, pandemic spread, the weather, etc. The risk is that, if the data isn't suitably anonymized, the breach of privacy could extend to private activities conducted in the privacy of a person's home.

Obama vs Technology

[Commentary] President Obama's disdain for new media has become so consistent that it is hard to dismiss as mere posturing.

Now that he has to govern, President Obama would just as soon dispense with all those niggling critics carping about his policies. It was better in the days when three liberals -- say Cronkite, Reasoner, and Brinkley -- had a monopoly over deciding what the news was every day, and synthesized it every night on TV. Then they let the New York Times echo those views the next morning. Those were the days.

And it is beginning to dawn on this White House that the Internet is not its friend and, in fact, that the web stands for the opposite of what has emerged as the Obama administration's animating spirit. The Internet is centrifugal, dispersing power outward; the Obama administration is centripetal, concentrating power at the center.

The Federal Communications Commission recently announced that it will ignore its own previous determination -- and a court ruling -- and proceed to regulate broadband communications. President Obama may be no Charles II, but those who truly love freedom of expression should remain vigilant.

Federal Agencies Plead For Cybersecurity Ideas

A group of federal agencies opened an online forum to collect ideas from the public for what it is billing as its "game-change" cybersecurity initiative, calling for proposals for R&D projects as it continues its efforts to leverage government heft to shore up public and private information networks.

"I want to really emphasize that we want everyone to be thinking big, thinking novel," Jeannette Wing, assistant director of the National Science Foundation's Computer Science and Information Assurance Directorate, said at an event Wednesday launching the initiative. "The administration is very, very keen to see how the government can be working with the private sector on this along with academia." The new portal is a joint effort of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) and the National Coordination Office for Networking and Information Technology Research and Development (NITRD), a coalition of 14 agencies responsible for coordinating network research initiatives across the federal government. Participating departments and agencies include the NSF, NASA, National Security Agency and, most recently, the Department of Homeland Security.

Verizon moves forward on rural carrier LTE deals

More than a "couple dozen" rural wireless carriers have expressed interest in Verizon Wireless' 700 MHz LTE spectrum licensing proposal. And the company is in the process or formulating different business models for the deals, according to a company spokesman.

The carrier's business development team is working on two different types of deals, Verizon spokesman Jeffrey Nelson said. In one scenario, Verizon will build the network, and in the other the rural carriers will build the network. However, both deals include LTE data roaming. Within the next week or two, Nelson said, Verizon will launch a website explaining the potential benefits of the two types of deals to rural carriers and allow them to explore which model works best. Nelson added that Verizon is not "interested in mandating to anybody how they build [the network]." Verizon has picked Alcatel-Lucent and Ericsson as its primary LTE infrastructure vendors but rural carriers will not be required to use those vendors. However, Nelson said there may be some benefits from economies of scale to selecting the same vendors. How the deals will be structured is something that is being debated.

Execs View Telehealth As Game Changer

Through the use of telehealth technology, the US healthcare delivery systems will undergo a significant transformation that will improve healthcare outcomes and cut costs, a new study shows.

The study, conducted by research firm Penn Schoen Berland on behalf of Intel, interviewed 75 C-level executives at hospitals, home health organizations, and insurance companies. Among the findings, 89% of healthcare decision makers believe telehealth will transform healthcare in the next 10 years. The study also revealed that telehealth solutions, which deliver health-related services and information via telecommunications and computing technologies, are currently being used by two-thirds of healthcare professionals with an 87% satisfaction rate.

The UK Elections Consume the Blogosphere

The May 6 elections in the United Kingdom, which ended with a coalition government and a Conservative Party prime minister, received modest attention in the mainstream U.S. media. However, on social media, where geographic boundaries vanish, the blogosphere was consumed with the formation of the new British government.

For the week of May 10-14, fully 61% of the news links on blogs were about the British election according to the New Media Index from the Pew Research Center's Project for Excellence in Journalism. That was more than ten times the attention to the week's next largest subject and equaled the highest level of interest that any single topic has generated so far in 2010. (During the week of March 22-26-following the House's passage of health care reform-that subject also made up 61%.) That stands in stark contrast to the mainstream press, which devoted only 2% of its newshole to the British election the week of May 10-16, according to PEJ's News Coverage Index.

Google's Wi-Fi snooping earns it a class-action lawsuit

Google's secret Wi-Fi sniffing has prompted a class-action lawsuit that could force the company to pay up to $10,000 for each time it snatched data from unprotected hotspots, court documents show.

The lawsuit, which was filed by an Oregon woman and a Washington man in a Portland (OR) federal court on Monday, accused Google of violating federal privacy and data acquisition laws. "When Google created its data collection systems on its GSV [Google Street View] vehicles, it included wireless packet sniffers that, in addition to collecting the user's unique or chosen Wi-Fi network name (SSID information), the unique number given to the user's hardware used to broadcast a user's Wi-Fi signal (MAC address, the GSV data collection systems also collected data consisting of all or part of any documents, e-mails, video, audio, and VoIP information being sent over the network by the user [payload data]," the lawsuit stated. On Tuesday, the same plaintiffs filed a motion for a temporary restraining order to prevent Google from deleting the data, a move the company has said it would make "as soon possible." Oral arguments on the restraining order are scheduled for Monday before U.S. District Court Judge Janice Stewart.