December 2009

FCC gets Technical Assistance for Network Neutrality Proceeding

The Federal Communications Commission announced that the Chief of the FCC's Office of Engineering & Technology (OET) has established a Technical Advisory Process to ensure that decisions in the Commission's proceeding on the open Internet reflect a thorough understanding of current technology and future technology trends. The process will provide an inclusive, open, and transparent forum for obtaining the best technical data and insights from a broad range of stakeholders. The Technical Advisory Process was called for in the FCC's October 22, 2009 Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. OET has now established a technical working group comprised of engineers and technologists from across the FCC's bureaus and offices to receive information from stakeholders on the technical issues in the open Internet proceeding. The working group will hold ex parte meetings with engineers and other interested parties to understand the range of views in the technical community on the issues presented by the open Internet rulemaking, identify any areas of common ground between stakeholders, and clarify the scope of key differences. In addition, FCC engineers from the working group will be integrated into other teams within the Commission considering the various issues raised in the open Internet proceeding. The Technical Advisory Process will include a workshop on December 8, 2009 starting at 10 a.m. in the Commission meeting room, which will be open to the public and live streamed via the Internet. The workshop will consist of tutorial presentations by experts on network management practices for various Internet access service delivery platforms, followed by questions from the Commission's technical working group and members of the public.

FCC Updates Eligible E-Rate Services Including VoIP

In this report and order and further notice of proposed rulemaking, the Federal Communications Commission addresses and seeks comment on issues regarding the services eligible for funding under the schools and libraries universal service support mechanism, also known as the E-rate program. First, the FCC modifies its rules to expressly include interconnected voice over Internet protocol (VoIP) and text messaging as eligible services under the E-rate program. Second, the FCC releases the list of services that will be eligible for discounts for E-rate funding year 2010. Finally, the FCC seeks further comment on the eligibility of certain services in future funding years, as well as on proposed changes to the process for determining the services that will be eligible for support under the E-rate program

New Networks Foster Invention and Innovation

Digital Age Paul Reveres have been warning the world lately about the impending Internet lock-down that they fear will result from the growth in popularity of permission-based development environments such as Apple's iPhone. Unlike the World Wide Web where everybody is free to execute their ideas without having to obtain prior permission from an infrastructure provider, Apple requires developers to submit their iPhone applications for approval before they can be offered to the public. Critics, such as Harvard Law School Professor Jonathan Zittrain, worry that such regimes could suffocate the freewheeling nature of the Web and kill the innovation that emerges from such an environment. While innovation on the software layer may be on the endangered phenomenon list, Tuesday's presentations at the Supernova technology conference made it clear that today's broadband and social networks are enabling other kinds of innovations and collaborations.

From the "Be Careful What You Wish For" File: Ubiquitous Connectivity

Technophiles and U.S. policymakers have spent decades promising the public that a ubiquitously-networked society would be a people-powered-utopia filled with useful, actionable information. President Barack Obama's 2008 campaign is the most prominent example of how a group of people capitalized on this vision. Nevertheless, a thoughtless rush to make the Internet pervasive, and to connect with one another socially online could in fact poison the delicately-balanced relationships that exist in the rapidly vanishing concept of the "offline" world, warned several leading thinkers at Supernova, an annual conference on innovation on Tuesday. "We're not just communicating with people anymore with Twitter, we're communicating with urban space," argued Nokia's Adam Greenfield in an afternoon presentation on how Internet-connected embedded devices are changing the very notion of what it means to live in cities. Greenfield gave several examples of how emerging applications and the adoption of Internet protocol version 6 (ipv6) would enable everything to be connected through the Internet, and how that is starting to erode current, unquestioned assumptions underlying our everyday existence.

AT&T gives up on Verizon ad lawsuit

AT&T has dismissed its lawsuit against Verizon Wireless for using an advertisement that AT&T complained confused customers about its 3G wireless coverage. On Wednesday, AT&T formally dismissed the lawsuit. Last month, the wireless operator suffered a major legal setback when a judge rejected the company's request to force Verizon to pull its "There's A Map For That" advertising campaign.

Access and Technology: House Hearing on Arbitron

The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform held a hearing on Wednesday on a topic that doesn't usually reach our radar: the manner in which local radio stations receive the ratings that determine their audience size and advertising rates. The debate that took place highlighted the difficulty of creating a balance between using technology for outreach while preserving access for all groups. House Oversight Chairman Ed Towns (D-NY) suggested that flaws in Arbitron's methodology may be costing minority communities one of their most crucial organizing tools. "What's at stake is life and death of one of the most viable industries for people of color," said Rep Eleanor Holmes Norton (D-DC). Arbitron Chief Executive Officer Michael Skarzynski argued that much of the decline in audience is due to the general economic situation, as well as the particular difficulties facing the radio industry such as the rise of the Internet. He said the rating declines facing minority and urban radio stations have also emerged in other formats, including talk and Christian radio. But according to Univision's Ceril Shagrin, the disproportionate impact of the new methodology on specific audiences would suggest that at very least Arbitron is facing issues with its sample size. Federal Communications Commission member Mignon Clyburn was in the audience but admitted the FCC probably doesn't have jurisdiction over Arbitron.

Randy Michaels Appointed Tribune CEO

As a sign that Tribune Co. chief Sam Zell is stepping away from day-to-day operational duties, the board of directors named Randy Michaels as CEO and elected him to the board. Zell, who previously served as CEO, will remain chairman of the company. Michaels was appointed chief operating officer of Tribune in May 2008. Prior to that, he was executive vice president and CEO of Tribune's interactive and broadcast divisions. Michaels also served as chairman and CEO of Clear Channel Communications.

Cator Previews National Ed Tech Plan

As America's brand-new director of education technology, career educator Karen Cator underscores the determination of President Obama and Education Secretary Arne Duncan to develop "a transformative agenda" for the nation's schools and colleges. She said the Department of Education will unveil the first draft of the administration's National Education Technology Plan next month. The plan will seek to bring to fruition the President's vow to make the United States first in the world in the number of college graduates by 2020 and to give every willing student at least one year of postsecondary education. The plan will address the imperatives of global competition, Cator said, but also will stress the importance of global interdependence. It will focus on ensuring effective teachers are present "in every zip code," on seamlessly bridging the gap between the wide array of technology students use outside of school and the more limited technology available to them in the classroom. She said America's ed-tech plan will promote careers in science, technology, engineering, and math--but now will add an emphasis on the arts, because, as Cator explained, creativity is essential to lifelong success in the age of technology.

If I Still Worked at Fox News...

The former host of Fox News Watch calls his former employer "the right-wing partial-news-but-mostly-opinion network." Of Glenn Beck he says, "He is an embarrassment to all true conservatives, men and women who believe sincerely, thoughtfully and sensibly that the role of government in American life should be limited."

Gates Foundation Announces New Support for Public Libraries to Help Provide Broadband Access for More Americans

The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation committed nearly $3.4 million in grants to bolster Internet connections for libraries in five states. It also announced partnerships with 14 additional states to help public libraries compete for federal broadband stimulus funds. Nationally, libraries report that patron demand for high-speed Internet access is growing faster than their ability to provide increased bandwidth. A recent American Library Association study reports that 60 percent of all libraries say their current Internet speed is insufficient. State libraries in Arkansas ($735,207), Kansas ($363,099), Massachusetts ($367,789), New York ($947,517), and Virginia ($977,468) received foundation funds to execute statewide plans to improve and maintain Internet connections in local libraries. Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Delaware, Idaho, Kentucky, Montana, North Carolina, Nebraska, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Utah, Vermont, and Washington will participate in the foundation's new Opportunity Online broadband grant program, which will help libraries develop proposals for federal broadband stimulus funding from the National Telecommunications and Information Administration's (NTIA) Broadband Technology Opportunities Program established through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. The five states receiving Gates Foundation grants to implement local broadband improvement plans have partnered with the foundation since early 2009 to develop strategies for upgrading and sustaining Internet connections in libraries, as well as raising federal E-rate participation rates among libraries. Arkansas, Kansas, Massachusetts, New York, and Virginia were selected to receive foundation grants because they had a high number of libraries without high-speed Internet access that were struggling to increase their bandwidth for patrons. The state libraries of California and Texas also participated in the program and will be eligible for grants in early 2010.