September 2009

Health Care, Economy, LA Fire, Afghanistan Dominate News

In a week when no one story dominated the media landscape, two big domestic issues, an emerging overseas challenge, a natural disaster and an unnatural crime led the roster of top stories. Indeed, the leading story last week varied depending on which media sector one visited. The No. 1 story, for the sixth time in seven weeks, was the health care debate, which filled 14% of the newshole from August 31-September 6, according to the Pew Research Center's Project for Excellence in Journalism. While coverage was up from the previous week (11%), that still represents a significant drop in attention from the peak weeks earlier in the summer, when political wrangling and angry town hall meetings fueled the narrative. But the event that actually drove the coverage has not even occurred yet—Barack Obama's September 9 speech to a joint session of Congress, widely viewed as a pivotal moment for his health care initiative. With that as a backdrop, it is a good bet that coverage of the subject will spike significantly this week.

Report: Obama administration improves openness

President Barack Obama's policies on secrecy get higher grades for openness than those of President George W. Bush, yet there's still room for improvement, says a coalition of public interest groups. In a report issued Tuesday, the coalition says the new administration has made major strides toward more disclosure, including the recent release of Justice Department memos on Bush administration interrogation policies and Obama's embrace of greater openness under the Freedom of Information Act. The report noted, however, that the government has resisted release of photos from Army interrogation investigations; has not backed away from occasional use of the state secrets privilege; and has argued in court for secrecy regarding the role of former Vice President Dick Cheney in the Valerie Plame affair.

Obama warns U.S. teens of perils of Facebook

President Barack Obama warned American teenagers on Tuesday of the dangers of putting too much personal information on Internet social networking sites, saying it could come back to haunt them in later life. "Well, let me give you some very practical tips. First of all, I want everybody here to be careful about what you post on Facebook, because in the YouTube age, whatever you do, it will be pulled up again later somewhere in your life," the President said. "And when you're young, you make mistakes and you do some stupid stuff. And I've been hearing a lot about young people who -- you know, they're posting stuff on Facebook, and then suddenly they go apply for a job and somebody has done a search." President Obama referred several times to "mistakes" he had made when he was at school but offered no specifics.

FCC Reports on Public Emergency Preparedness Review

Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski released a comprehensive report on the Commission's ability to respond to natural disasters, terrorist attacks, public health emergencies, and other large-scale events. The report, prepared by the Commission's Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau, is in response to the 30-day, top-to-bottom state-of-readiness review launched by Chairman Genachowski as one of his first actions at the agency. During emergencies, the FCC's primary mission is to ensure that essential communications networks and services are operable, reliable, and quickly restored when necessary so that the American public can communicate and receive emergency information. Equally important is the FCC's responsibility to ensure that America's public safety officials and first responders have the tools they need to protect lives, property, and strategic infrastructure. The report concludes that the Commission is prepared to respond to communications emergencies and perform its mission. The report also identifies a number of areas in which the FCC can improve its emergency planning and response: education and training, outreach and collaboration, emergency operations and alerts, and network analysis. The initiatives highlighted below have been completed, are underway, or will be launched in the near future. Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau Chief Jamie Barnett said the FCC could seek expanded authority from Congress to obtain network outage information from cable companies and other Internet service providers during emergencies. The FCC currently has the authority to monitor the resiliency of landline and cellular Internet networks, but the FCC has less flexibility to regulate Internet services offered by "information services" such as cable.

Connected Nation One Link To Derail New Broadband Policy -- Connect The Dots

The House Commerce Committee will be holding oversight hearings regarding both the broadband stimulus grant programs and Federal Communications Commission's efforts on devising a National Broadband Plan. It would be a shame if the stimulus mapping/grant program and the broadband plan were considered in isolation, because they are, together, pieces of the same puzzle. Certainly the telephone and cable industries are considering them together, and using the leverage on one to influence the other to reach the inevitable conclusion that no new broadband policies are needed and that everything will be just fine if we leave the companies in control. Ignore our slumping world rankings for broadband. Ignore the lack of choice. Let's try to connect the dots into a long silver thread.

Globally, 445M Broadband Subscribers

If there was any lingering doubt that broadband was the new platform for technology innovation, new data out today from trade group The Broadband Forum should put it to rest for good. The number of broadband subscribers around the world grew to 445 million in the second quarter, led by China, with 93.6 million, followed by the U.S., with 86.2 million. Many of them are using DSL connections to log onto the Internet, the report found. The data also shows that over the past 12 months, Latin America and Eastern Europe were the fastest-growing broadband regions. Meanwhile Europe has emerged as the hub of IPTV activity, with some 13.6 million IPTV users as of the end of June. France remains the "champion" IPTV country, with more than 7 million subscribers.

Debunking Myths about Government-Run Broadband

[Commentary] Last week, as we discovered quite a few of the 2,200 NOFA applications were from local governments and public utilities, forces from the dark side started belittling these proposals. We're well past the time for the feds to embrace and encourage seriously the role of local government and their constituents in not only the stimulus process, but also in the national broadband strategy itself. We've let the lie that governments can't run effective networks fester and poison the broadband discussion. It's time for an antidote. Myth 1. Government shouldn't be in the business of running broadband networks. Myth 2. Government isn't capable of running an effective and/or profitable network. Myth 3. Incumbents need protection from unfair competition because local governments have tax and tax levying advantages.

Why All Schools Need Fiber

[Commentary] While there's little consensus as to whether every home and business will someday require a fiber pipe, there should be no debate that every school in America needs fiber. The reasoning is simple: only fiber can support the demands for simultaneous capacity that the classrooms of today and tomorrow require.
Anything less than fiber means teachers will be handcuffed in terms of how much they can incorporate online experiences into their lesson plans. Schools won't be able to realize all the efficiencies and opportunities of their counterparts in other countries that have made a commitment to fiber. And ultimately our students will suffer from having limited access to a truly 21st century education. With all this in mind, our national broadband plan must acknowledge this basic reality of America's broadband demands. The plan can't afford to allow the debate over residential broadband's future and the sacred cow of maintaining strict technological neutrality to obfuscate what our schools truly need. And the simple truth is that our schools need fiber. But that's just one component of the national fiber plan that should be at the core of any national broadband plan. Many more details on what that national fiber plan should include and how we can go about accomplishing these goals to come in future posts. For now, though, let's push everything else aside, and come to agreement on the straightforward, justifiable, and achievable goal that every school in America needs and deserves fiber. The future of 21st century education in America depends on it.

Fast, Universal Broadband: Dirty Secret about the Roadblock

Where's the fastest broadband service? The Federal Communications Commission's effort to expand availability of high-speed Internet access throughout the US offers a clue as to where -- and why -- the best services exist. Last month the FCC asked companies, organizations and individuals to comment on the state of broadband in the US as part of its now-annual "706 Inquiry." The FCC will use the information to help with the National Broadband Plan, which aims to make high-speed Internet access available to every US resident. As responses start to come in, many service providers (including Verizon and Comcast) have made it clear that the FCC's current standard of 768 kbps down and 200 kbps up is an adequate speed definition for broadband Internet access. Naturally, their stance has drawn criticism and accusations that it is setting a low bar for the definition of broadband, especially for certain public usage.

Metrics Workshop: Measuring Current Network Versus Internet Users' Needs

The Federal Communication Commission's workshop on how to best benchmark broadband for evaluating the various dimensions of broadband across geographic areas highlighted the difference between measuring the current network versus focusing on Internet users' needs. Richard Clarke, assistant vice president of public policy at AT&T, said that the FCC should benchmark broadband very broadly. This would allow the agency to cope with different classes of user necessity and service differentiation across user capabilities and time of day. Clarke also argued that the FCC must establish benchmarks that do not vary over time. Taking a different point of view was Harold Feld, legal director of Public Knowledge and Catherine Sandoval, Assistant Professor of Law, Santa Clara University. Feld and Sandoral said that the focus of benchmarks should be upon the American citizens' right to use broadband - and should not be limited by usage availability or cost. They also said that FCC benchmarks must somewhat be adaptive to the changing needs of consumers, and will inevitably change over time.