Daily Digest 6/01/2020 (Happy Birthday, Kipton Roderick)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Broadband/Internet

Broadband Subscriptions Are Up...But What's Behind the Numbers?  |  Read below  |  Kevin Taglang  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Rural Broadband Provider Organizations Ask USDA to Relax "Onerous" ReConnect Award Rules  |  Read below  |  Joan Engebretson  |  telecompetitor
Community Broadband: The Fast, Affordable Internet Option That's Flying Under the Radar  |  Read below  |  Claire Park  |  Research  |  New America

Wireless

Verizon: As Lines Between Wireline and Wireless Blur, Home Broadband is Just Another Device  |  Read below  |  Bernie Arnason  |  telecompetitor
FCC Grants Makah Tribe Spectrum Access for Broadband During Pandemic  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Federal Communications Commission
FCC Commissioner Starks Remarks to the Commercial Spaceflight Federation Webinar  |  Read below  |  FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission
Ligado to FCC: NTIA's Petition Fails on All Counts  |  Multichannel News
Iridium: FCC Spectrum Move Ignores Important Facts  |  Wall Street Journal

Health

Tech’s First Big Plan to Tackle Covid-19 Stumbles: ‘An App Is Not Going to Fix This’  |  Wall Street Journal

Education

As Virus Keeps Kids From Schools, New Figures Show Millions Lack Home Internet  |  Read below  |  Bill Lucia  |  Route Fifty
Andy Kessler: Give Online Learning an Upgrade  |  Wall Street Journal
Op-Ed: Closing the Communication Chasm for Schools and Families  |  EdSurge

Platforms/Content

Senator Cruz Calls for Criminal Investigation Into Twitter for ‘Blatant and Willful Violation’ of U.S. Sanctions on Iran  |  Read below  |  Sen Ted Cruz (R-TX)  |  Press Release  |  US Senate
Chairman Pai Challenges Twitter After It Warns About President Trump Tweet  |  Read below  |  Todd Shields  |  Bloomberg
Trump's Social Media Regulation Push Faces Key Hurdle at the FCC  |  Read below  |  Reuters
How President Trump got the FCC involved in his war against Twitter  |  Read below  |  Marguerite Reardon  |  C|Net
GOP deeply divided over Trump's social media crackdown  |  Hill, The
Rep Khanna calls for internet 'fairness doctrine' in response to controversial tweets by President Trump  |  Hill, The
Trump social media order starts off on shaky legal ground  |  Hill, The
Twitter Stands Strong Against Trump Call to Violence, Removing White Supremacists Must Come Next  |  Change the Terms Coalition
Twitter Had Been Drawing a Line for Months When Trump Crossed It  |  New York Times
How Twitter made its own rules for Trump to break  |  Los Angeles Times
Peter Kafka: Why Big Tech isn’t fighting President Trump in public this time  |  Vox
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg defends handling of Trump posts on protests  |  USA Today
Facebook workers rebel over Mark Zuckerberg's refusal to act against Trump  |  Guardian, The
Let's go through President Trump's terrible internet censorship order, line by line. Spoiler: you can't nationalize Twitter  |  Vox
Op-ed: Trump's social media executive order is a huge opportunity  |  Hill, The
Preston Padden: President Trump Echoes Nixon in Targeting Twitter  |  Wall Street Journal
Editorial: The media can’t just ignore Trump’s outrageous tweets. Here’s why  |  Los Angeles Times
Fast facts about Americans’ views of social media companies as Trump-Twitter dispute grows  |  Pew Research Center
Dealing with the Internet’s split personality  |  Read below  |  Robert Samuelson  |  Analysis  |  Washington Post
Joe Biden doesn’t like President Trump’s Twitter order, but still wants to revoke Section 230  |  Read below  |  Makena Kelly  |  Vox
Getting to the Source of Infodemics: It’s the Business Model  |  Read below  |  Nathalie Maréchal, Rebecca MacKinnon, Jessica Dheere  |  Research  |  New America

Journalism

TV Stations Broke Law by Airing Amazon Propaganda as News, Experts Say  |  Read below  |  Karl Bode  |  Vice
Chairman Pai on Local Broadcasters Covering Recent Protests & Violence  |  Federal Communications Commission
Journalists Under Fire: Reporters Covering Protests Face Rubber Bullets, Tear Gas, Arrests  |  Variety
Journalists Targeted at Protests by Police, Hit With Rubber Bullet and Tear Gas  |  Wrap, The
CNN Crew Is Arrested on Live Television While Covering Minneapolis Protests  |  New York Times
PEN America CEO says CNN Arrests akin to something out of an authoritarian state  |  PEN America
Louisville police shoot reporter, cameraman with pepper balls in middle of live broadcast  |  Hill, The
NAB Condemns Police Targeting of WAVE News Crew  |  Multichannel News
Journalists voice support for Fox News crew hounded by protesters: 'Unacceptable'  |  Hill, The
Microsoft sacks journalists to replace them with robots  |  Guardian, The
A Reporter’s Cry on Live TV: ‘I’m Getting Shot! I’m Getting Shot!’  |  New York Times
Record Ratings and Record Chaos on Cable News  |  New York Times

Children and Media

As Children Spend More Time Online, Predators Follow  |  Wall Street Journal
Senator Markey Leads Bipartisan Call for Investigation into TikTok’s Children’s Privacy Practices  |  US Senate

Security

Exim Mail Transfer Agent Actively Exploited by Russian GRU Cyber Actors  |  National Security Agency

Stories From Abroad

Jimmy Lai: Do My Tweets Really Threaten China’s National Security?  |  New York Times
European government officials call for tech companies to loosen grip on contact-tracing technology  |  Washington Post
Today's Top Stories

Broadband/Internet

Broadband Subscriptions Are Up...But What's Behind the Numbers?

Back in April, a Pew Research Center survey found that 53% of U.S. adults say the internet has been essential for them personally during the pandemic. Another 34% say it has been important. Those attitudes are reflected in increased traffic over home broadband networks. More people and more devices are connecting to do more things while sheltered at home. With millions of people not yet connected to broadband networks -- either because they are unavailable or unaffordable -- many a public interest policy wonk (including me) have been rooting for a massive upswing in internet subscriptions. As a Washington Post editorial highlighted this week, for students who can’t access live-streamed classes, for the ill who can’t virtually consult with a doctor, for isolated individuals who can’t find human connection on their laptop screens, we all need broadband and we need it now. Earlier this month, Leichtman Research Group found that the largest broadband service providers -- the cable and telephone companies that serve about 96% of the total broadband market -- added 1,165,000 new subscribers in the first quarter of this year. To put that number into perspective, just over 42% of all new broadband subscribers who signed up in the last year did so in January, February, and March. In fact, the first quarter of 2020 saw more new broadband subscribers than in any quarter since 2015. In comparison, there were just 955,000 new subscribers in the first quarter of 2019.

Rural Broadband Provider Organizations Ask USDA to Relax "Onerous" ReConnect Award Rules

Joan Engebretson  |  telecompetitor

NTCA — The Rural Broadband Association and the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA) asked the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) to relax certain rules for the ReConnect rural broadband funding program. The ReConnect program covers some of the costs of deploying broadband to unserved rural areas where build-out costs are high. ReConnect 100% grant awards require matching funds, and currently, recipients must spend all matching funds before they can begin using grant funding. The associations ask the RUS to modify that requirement, arguing that it is “unnecessarily onerous – especially at a time when providers are compelled to monitor cash flows as customers increasingly struggle to pay bills.” Instead, the letter recommends that service providers should only be required to match 25% of the amount drawn from grant funds within each fiscal year.

Community Broadband: The Fast, Affordable Internet Option That's Flying Under the Radar

Claire Park  |  Research  |  New America

With at least 20 million people across the United States lacking broadband service, community and tribal broadband networks offer a much-needed opportunity to expand and improve internet access across the country. These networks, which include municipal or public option networks, today serve more than 900 communities nationwide. This report details how these networks have succeeded in connecting unserved communities, challenged incumbent private-sector providers to deliver higher-quality and more affordable internet, and expanded opportunities for education, job creation, and economic growth. Unfortunately, as many as 20 states prevent localities from forming their own networks. These restrictive state laws should be repealed so that local governments can decide for themselves whether these networks are best for their communities. Policymakers should acknowledge the value of community broadband networks and support, rather than undermine, efforts to build them. The Community Broadband Act, for example, would prevent states from creating laws that prevent cities and localities from creating their own broadband internet networks. Doing so will improve internet access and affordability, better connect people to new opportunities, strengthen local economies, and help close the digital divide.

Wireless

Verizon: As Lines Between Wireline and Wireless Blur, Home Broadband is Just Another Device

Bernie Arnason  |  telecompetitor

Verizon executive Ronan Dunne, group CEO for Verizon Consumer, laid out a vision for Verizon 5G Home that foresees a time when consumers will buy home broadband service in the same way they buy wireless service today. It is just buying another line, or another device in Dunne’s vision, just like consumers do today with their wireless buying habits. “The nature of the line between the wireless business and wireline business is blurring,” said Dunne. “I don’t necessarily see them in the medium term as being two discreet markets anymore.” Instead of a 3 or 4 line wireless plan, consumers will buy a 4 or 5 line plan, with one line being their home broadband. Or they think of home broadband as just another device, another smartphone if you will. If a customer moves, they simply take their home broadband with them, just like they take their smartphone today.

FCC Grants Makah Tribe Spectrum Access for Broadband During Pandemic

Press Release  |  Federal Communications Commission

The Federal Communications Commission has granted an emergency Special Temporary Authority request filed by the Makah Tribe to use unassigned spectrum in the 2.5 GHz band to provide wireless broadband service over its reservation as part of its emergency COVID-19 pandemic response. The Tribe is located within Washington State. The temporary grant of authority is effective for 60 days.

FCC Commissioner Starks Remarks to the Commercial Spaceflight Federation Webinar

FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission

The American space industry holds tremendous potential to address [the challenge of the digital divide] through next-generation satellite broadband. The coming proliferation of small low-earth-orbit satellites promises to unleash internet connectivity with latency and speeds superior to existing satellite broadband options and competitive with cable and fiber offerings. And they will reach places that, due to difficult terrain and distance from population centers, have not shared in the benefits of expanding terrestrial networks. 

China is developing multiple government-backed satellite broadband providers that could compete with American companies to carry traffic around the world. While the Chinese government describes its effort as focused on domestic customers, we cannot count on China’s forbearance in any important technology, particularly if it might carry sensitive communications. The Federal Communications Commission must continue to adopt satellite policies that encourage American leadership in this area.

Education

As Virus Keeps Kids From Schools, New Figures Show Millions Lack Home Internet

Bill Lucia  |  Route Fifty

The US Census Bureau estimates that nearly 1-in-10 households with school-aged children lack a consistent internet connection that can be used for educational purposes at a time when millions of kids have been forced out of classrooms by the coronavirus. Among 60 million households with children in public or private schools, about 5.4 million, or just over 9%, have internet available only “sometimes,” “rarely,” or “never” for educational purposes, the estimates suggest. About 3.2 million of those households with limited internet service earned under $35,000 a year, meaning that among 16.6 million households captured by the data that earned less than that sum, about 20% are lacking dependable internet access. The findings also highlight disparities by race. About 16% (1.4 million out of 9.2 million) of black households with school-aged kids are estimated to “sometimes,” “rarely,” or “never” have an internet connection for educational purposes. The same is true for just 7% (2.2 million of 32 million) of white households. The figure for Hispanic and Latino households was about 10% (1.3 million of 13 million).

Platforms/Content

Senator Cruz Calls for Criminal Investigation Into Twitter for ‘Blatant and Willful Violation’ of U.S. Sanctions on Iran

Sen Ted Cruz (R-TX)  |  Press Release  |  US Senate

Sen Ted Cruz (R-TX) called on Attorney General Bill Barr and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin to investigate Twitter for willfully violating American sanctions on Iran by providing social media accounts and services to the Supreme Leader of the Islamic Republic, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and the Iranian Foreign Minister, Javad Zarif. Both officials are designated under Executive Order (E.O) 13876 for connections to the Office of the Supreme Leader of Iran, which is the world's leading state sponsor of terrorism.

Chairman Pai Challenges Twitter After It Warns About President Trump Tweet

Todd Shields  |  Bloomberg

Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai challenged Twitter over a bellicose posting from Iran’s top leader hours after the company put a warning about glorifying violence on a tweet from President Donald Trump. “Serious question for @Twitter: Do these tweets from Supreme Leader of Iran @khamenei_ir violate “Twitter Rules about glorifying violence”? Chairman Pai said in a tweet. He attached screen shots of May 22 tweets from Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei predicting the eventual elimination of Israel. The post was in apparent reference to Twitter slapping a rule-violation notice on a tweet from Trump that included the phrase “when the looting starts, the shooting starts” in reference to unrest in Minneapolis.

Trump's Social Media Regulation Push Faces Key Hurdle at the FCC

  |  Reuters

President Donald Trump's effort to regulate social media companies' content decisions may face an uphill battle from Federal Communications Commission regulators who have previously said they cannot oversee the conduct of internet firms. In August 2018, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai said, "The government is not here to regulate these platforms. We don't have the power to do that." Former FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell, a Republican, wrote on Twitter that the review ordered by President Trump is "based on political #speech management of platforms. So many wobbly parts to this govt 'nudge.' I don’t see how it survives." 

Another barrier is timing. The FCC will spend at least a few months reviewing and likely seeking public comment before potentially drafting proposed regulations. It could take a year or longer to finalize any rules, long after the November presidential election.

How President Trump got the FCC involved in his war against Twitter

Marguerite Reardon  |  C|Net

President Donald Trump is asking the Federal Communications Commission to review Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, the law that gives social media companies their legal protection. The president wants rules that'll let the agency investigate complaints that social media companies discriminate against certain speech on their platforms. Any role in policing social media will be awkward for the FCC, which has cast itself as anti-regulation under Ajit Pai, its Trump-appointed chairman. It's unclear if the FCC even has the authority to make calls about whether social media companies play fair. And it's certain that any FCC action will be challenged in court. At the heart of Trump's executive order is the allegation that social media sites censor conservative viewpoints they disagree with. President Trump wants the FCC to establish regulations that clarify the parameters of the good faith effort that Section 230 requires online companies must make when deciding whether to delete or modify content. 

Dealing with the Internet’s split personality

Robert Samuelson  |  Analysis  |  Washington Post

A central question of our time is whether we can continue enjoying the Good Internet while suppressing the Bad Internet. The greatest threat to ordinary Americans comes from the Internet’s role in providing so-called critical infrastructure — cyber-networks for finance, power, transportation, health care, communications and shopping, to name a few. I am not a cyber-expert, but here’s a brief outline of what I think desirable:

  1. Build a cyber-firewall — as Russia and China are attempting to do — to keep out mass foreign attacks. They close their cyber-borders; we leave ours open. It’s a self-inflicted wound. (China’s and Russia’s policies also reflect a desire to purge the Internet of subversive political views.)
  2. Switch cyber-traffic used for operational control (financial transfers, power distribution, transport networks) to private networks and reserve the Internet for nonessential informational exchanges. This would reduce, though not eliminate, the threat of losing critical infrastructure.
  3. Build redundancy into the system, with separate defenses and passwords, so that breaches in one system can be instantly remedied in an attack.
  4. Mandate that the most sophisticated computer chips be made in the United States. In case of a crisis, we wouldn’t immediately face shortages of chips needed by the military.

I recognize that this approach represents a basic switch in U.S. policy, which has favored an “open” Internet not burdened with nationalistic policies. But let’s face it: That game is long lost. Like it or not, the Internet is being twisted to serve national goals.

Joe Biden doesn’t like President Trump’s Twitter order, but still wants to revoke Section 230

Makena Kelly  |  Vox

Former Vice President Joe Biden still wants to repeal Section 230, the pivotal internet law that provides social media companies like Facebook and Twitter with broad legal immunity over content posted by their users, a campaign spokesperson said. Still, the campaign emphasized key disagreements with the executive order signed by President Donald Trump May 28. Earlier in 2020, Joe Biden said that Section 230 should be "revoked, immediately." In a statement May 28 responding to President Trump's executive order, Biden campaign spokesperson Bill Russo said that “it will not be the position of any future Biden Administration … that the First Amendment means private companies must provide a venue for, and amplification of, the president’s falsehoods, lest they become the subject of coordinated retaliation by the federal government.” Still, Biden’s position on Section 230 remains unchanged, as a spokesperson for the campaign said that the former vice president maintains his position that the law should be revoked and that he would seek to propose legislation that would hold social media companies accountable for knowingly platforming falsehoods. 

Getting to the Source of Infodemics: It’s the Business Model

Nathalie Maréchal, Rebecca MacKinnon, Jessica Dheere  |  Research  |  New America

This report argues that Facebook, Twitter, and Google’s targeted advertising business models, and the opaque algorithmic systems that support them, are the root cause of their failure to staunch the flow of misinformation. This report reinforces the need to adopt a human rights framework for platform accountability. We propose concrete areas where Congress needs to act to mitigate the harms of misinformation and other dangerous speech without compromising free expression and privacy: transparency and accountability for online advertising, starting with political ads; federal privacy law; and corporate governance reform.

Journalism

TV Stations Broke Law by Airing Amazon Propaganda as News, Experts Say

Karl Bode  |  Vice

Recently, 11 local broadcasters were caught airing “news” segments that were actually advertisements praising Amazon’s handling of the COVID-19 crisis. Experts say the ads—which featured an Amazon public relations representative pretending to be a reporter—not only violated the law, but are a shining example of how media consolidation is slowly destroying quality local journalism. The ads were part of an Amazon press release lauding the company for its “innovation” during the COVID-19 crisis. And while some ethical reporters correctly balked at the idea of running marketing fluff as news, some stations ran the prepared segment as hard news without informing viewers they were watching an Amazon infomercial.  Not only did the local broadcasters not acknowledge that the “news” report came from Amazon, they falsely identified an Amazon PR representative as a reporter. “This practice became very common in the early 00s as consolidation drove cost-cutting which meant downsizing local newsrooms while still needing to produce the same content,” said Public Knowledge's Harold Feld. “So local stations began just running whatever companies sent them to provide enough content for their local news show.”

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2020. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2019