Daily Digest 12/16/2019 (Flawed broadband speed tests)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Broadband/Internet

Net neutrality supporters ask court to reconsider ruling that upheld FCC repeal  |  Read below  |  Tony Romm  |  Washington Post
Why flawed broadband speed tests have devastating consequences  |  Read below  |  Marguerite Reardon  |  
No matter where you live, rural broadband is a big issue in Virginia  |  Read below  |  Mark Sickles, Nick Rush  |  Op-Ed  |  Washington Post
U alumni in Greater Minnesota say broadband means more than just connectivity. It means productivity.  |  Read below  |  University of Minnesota Alumni Association

Wireless/Spectrum

T-Mobile-Sprint Trial: A Debate About Phone Bills  |  Read below  |  Sarah Krouse  |  Wall Street Journal
T-Mobile tried and failed to merge with Dish years ago, John Legere says  |  Vox
AT&T Consumer 5G Begins: The Slow Rollout of Super-Fast 5G  |  Read below  |  Klint Finley  |  Wired
How Will Congress Spend Over $40 Billion in C-Band Auction Revenues?  |  Read below  |  Mark Colwell  |  Voqal
Cisco’s OpenRoaming promises to provide seamless wireless connection with automatic logins  |  Financial Times

Telecom

How the Loss of the Landline Is Changing Family Life  |  Read below  |  Julia Cho  |  Atlantic, The
FCC Seeks to Refresh the Record on Truth-in-Billing Rules  |  Federal Communications Commission
FCC Proposing Nearly $10M Fine of Against Campaign Consultant for Spoofed Robocalls Made Leading Up to CA State Election  |  Federal Communications Commission

Health

Turning Barbershops into Telehealth Centers  |  Read below  |  Craig Settles  |  Op-Ed  |  Government Technology

Security/Privacy

House National Security Subcommittee Chairman Lynch Seeks Info From Apple, Google On Foreign Entities Accessing US App Data  |  US House of Representatives
Google Hands Feds 1,500 Phone Locations In Unprecedented ‘Geofence’ Search  |  Forbes
Somebody’s Watching: Hackers Breach Ring Home Security Cameras  |  New York Times

Content

Google Maps has now photographed 10 million miles in Street View  |  C|Net
Why Do We Still Pay Only $10 a Month for Music?  |  Rolling Stone

Labor

Google Culture War Escalates as Era of Transparency Wanes  |  Bloomberg
NBC digital news division officially unionizes  |  Hill, The

Television

AT&T TV to Roll Out in February, Company Says It Will Drive Fiber Penetration  |  Multichannel News

Platforms

Roslyn Layton: The FTC’s privacy settlement with Facebook is just right  |  American Enterprise Institute
Tech Giants Race for Streaming Deals, but Twitch Remains King  |  New York Times
Prime Leverage: How Amazon Wields Power in the Technology World  |  New York Times

Elections & Media

2020 Campaigns Throw Their Hands Up on Disinformation  |  New York Times

Research

Striking Tech Findings From 2019  |  Read below  |  John Gramlich  |  Research  |  Pew Research Center

Stories From Abroad

Taiwan is battling a wave of online disinformation from China  |  Los Angeles Times
Today's Top Stories

Broadband/Internet

Net neutrality supporters ask court to reconsider ruling that upheld FCC repeal

Tony Romm  |  Washington Post

The fight to reinstate network neutrality rules could return to federal court, if public-interest advocates, consumer groups, and tech companies including Mozilla get their way [as well as the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society]. The groups asked a panel of judges to rehear a case that upheld a Federal Communications Commission decision to repeal the government’s open-Internet rules.

In Oct, the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit determined that the FCC acted lawfully when it voted in 2017 to unwind the protections that had required AT&T, Comcast, Verizon, and other telecom giants to treat all Web traffic equally. But the petitioners argued in filings Dec 13 that the DC Circuit erred in its reasoning. Some said judges misinterpreted decades-old legal precedent, giving the FCC too much leeway without considering the facts, and they asked some or all of the panel to reconsider the decision to uphold the repeal. Mozilla and its allies also faulted the FCC for having “abdicated its ability to regulate the behavior of ISPs for the first time in its history.” It is ultimately up to the judges whether to grant the request, which some net neutrality advocates concede is far from guaranteed. But net neutrality backers stress the request for a rehearing reflects their unwavering push to restore the widely supported open-Internet protections two years after the FCC decided to dismantle them.

“It’s critically important to the future to the Internet that net neutrality and important FCC oversight, get reinstated,” said Benton Senior Fellow and Public Advocate Gigi Sohn. She noted that advocates “should use every means possible, including the rehearing petition,” in their efforts to restore net neutrality.  Andrew Jay Schwartzman, senior counselor for the Benton Institute, said, “Changes in the way Internet service is delivered and other facts that the panel overlooked justify a different result: reversal of all elements of the FCC’s decision."

Why flawed broadband speed tests have devastating consequences

Marguerite Reardon  |  C|Net 

The question of just how fast your home internet service is seems pretty straightforward. Unfortunately, how the broadband industry gets at the answer is messy and complicated, and over the last few weeks, that's caused controversy. The stakes are high. The Federal Communications Commission uses data it collects to produce reports, such as the Measuring Broadband America and the Broadband Deployment reports, to set policy and determine where to deploy resources to promote broadband adoption. Much of the data the FCC gets to populate these reports is supplied by the broadband and wireless companies themselves, or in the case of the speed test, a third party that also contracts with these companies. The result is information that often paints a rosy picture of wireless and broadband in the US. 

"So we've got carriers exaggerating coverage for mobile broadband, flawed methodology producing bad maps for fixed broadband, and unreliable numbers on the speed of broadband. What's left?" said Gigi Sohn, an advisor to former FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler and a distinguished fellow at Georgetown Law Institute for Technology Law & Policy. "If there is no cop on the beat, the carriers will just make it like they're doing awesome and no need for any regulation or oversight."

No matter where you live, rural broadband is a big issue in Virginia

Mark Sickles, Nick Rush  |  Op-Ed  |  Washington Post

Broadband deployment stands to be an economic game-changer for rural and suburban communities, and the commonwealth must continue aggressively investing in bridging the digital divide. The economic implications of broadband expansion, while not necessarily as high profile as a new corporate headquarters, are staggering. State support to build out broadband infrastructure is repaid many times over by any measure of economic outcomes. But access to the Internet goes beyond dollars and cents. This is an equity issue. Today’s students need access to the learning tools the Internet offers whether they live in Floyd or Fairfax. Likewise, innovations in telehealth are unavailable to patients without high-speed Internet at home. Lives can be drastically improved and even saved by increasing broadband access. Broadband is increasingly comparable with roads or electricity — commerce and communication depend on them. Imagine how any modern community would fare without access to roads or electricity. Businesses would suffer. Homes would be sold at lower cost. Young people would move away. These are the challenges facing Virginia’s rural communities, where there are an estimated 600,000 people without access to the Internet

As members of the House Appropriations Committee, we took action to address the digital divide in the budget, increasing the state broadband grant program fivefold from a $4 million to $19 million. This $19 million grant round closed in early September and received more than $43 million in requests from 55 different localities. This is the fourth year in a row the program has received more than double in requests than available funds.

[Mark Sickles, a Democrat, and Nick Rush, a Republican, serve in the Virginia House of Delegates]

U alumni in Greater Minnesota say broadband means more than just connectivity. It means productivity.

“When we ask people around the state what concerns them most,” says Bernadine Joselyn of the Blandin Foundation, “they talk about education, health care, jobs. They don’t talk about broadband access, yet broadband is the common intersection for those things. Broadband supports them all.” The Blandin Foundation, based in Grand Rapids (MN) is a private foundation funded through a $407 million trust, established to strengthen rural Minnesota communities. Joselyn, director of public policy and engagement for the foundation, has worked with a number of communities in the Itasca area and elsewhere to ensure that rural voices inform public policy on broadband issues.

According to the MN Office of Broadband Development—housed in the MN Department of Employment and Economic Development (DEED)— in 2015, 85.8 percent of MN residences had 25 Mbps/3Mbps or greater connections, but only 68 percent of rural residences had that access. After the state and federal government, foundations, and providers, including rural cooperatives, began directing resources toward the disparity, by April 2019, 92.7 percent of households in MN had access to broadband. That’s a significant improvement, but it still leaves tens of thousands without full, affordable access. 

Wireless/Spectrum

T-Mobile-Sprint Trial: A Debate About Phone Bills

Sarah Krouse  |  Wall Street Journal

Whether Americans will pay more for cellphone service is at the center of arguments made by both sides battling last week over T-Mobile's purchase of Sprint. The coalition of state attorneys general that filed the antitrust lawsuit challenging the $26 billion merger fear consumers will pay more if the No. 3 and No. 4 U.S. carriers by subscribers combine, and that wireless industry competition will suffer. Plaintiffs’ lawyers said in court that even though T-Mobile promised not to raise the price of its rate plans for three years after the deal, it could pull back on device-related promotions. T-Mobile executives, meanwhile, testified that they would lower prices and better challenge larger rivals if the deal is approved. They said T-Mobile may have to raise prices if the transaction doesn’t happen, a situation that Chief Executive John Legere called a “worst nightmare.”

AT&T Consumer 5G Begins: The Slow Rollout of Super-Fast 5G

Klint Finley  |  Wired

AT&T is launching its new 5G service Dec 13 in 10 cities, including Los Angeles (CA), San Francisco (CA), and San Jose (CA). Notably, the service is based on real 5G standards, unlike AT&T’s earlier "5G Evolution" offering, which in reality was just a variety of 4G. Still, AT&T concedes that the new service for now will only deliver speeds comparable to “5G Evolution”—about 158 Mbps, or roughly similar to the fastest available 5G service in the US offered by competitor T-Mobile. With the new AT&T offering, all four large US carriers have some sort of 5G service available to some consumers. Even so, all of these networks are still a long way from living up to the 5G hype. Most offer only a modest speed boost over the more common 4G services, while the few delivering the fastest connections are spotty at best. Meanwhile, other countries—including South Korea, Switzerland, and China—are on track to make high-speed networks widely available by the end of 2019.

How Will Congress Spend Over $40 Billion in C-Band Auction Revenues?

Mark Colwell  |  Voqal

In the race to 5G, American wireless companies are sorely lacking one essential ingredient: mid-band spectrum. Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai announced that  the FCC will pursue a public auction of a portion of the 3.7 to 4.2 GHz spectrum band – also known as the C-Band – by the end of 2020. Senate Commerce Committee approved S. 2881, C-Band legislation that would modify the automatic Treasury deposit. The legislation would require at least 50% of C-Band proceeds (up to $40 billion) to be deposited in the Treasury. If the auction raises more than $40 billion, a higher percentage would be deposited in the Treasury. The bill also sets aside 10% of proceeds for broadband deployment in underserved and unserved areas. Some revenue may also go to the Spectrum Reallocation Fund for studying other spectrum bands. Once 50% for the Treasury and 10% for rural broadband are deducted, that leaves approximately $16.87 billion. So, what would happen to the rest of the cash? 

Telecom

How the Loss of the Landline Is Changing Family Life

Julia Cho  |  Atlantic, The

According to the federal government, the majority of American homes now use cellphones exclusively. “We don't even have a landline anymore,” people began to say proudly as the new millennium progressed. But this came with a quieter, secondary loss—the loss of the shared social space of the family landline. Meanwhile, the physical medium of communication has shifted from telephone poles, visually linking individual homes, to the elusive air. The environment of each call has shifted from a living room or a kitchen to anywhere, and as a result, callers spend time placing each other: In the early days of the phone, they often asked, “Are you there?,” but now they have graduated to “Where are you?” 

Even as smartphones have taken over, some people stand by their landlines. “I mainly want to keep it because it works when there is no power,” says Peter Eavis, a New York City–based journalist in his 50s and a father of two. “And as a veteran of 9/11, an actual NYC blackout, Hurricane Irene, and Superstorm Sandy, it gives me comfort.” But Eavis’s landline is on its way to being an anomaly, and a generation of children who never had one are coming of age. Eventually, for those who enjoyed—or at least grew accustomed to—the sound of a communal phone ringing in their homes, a moment of silence will be in order.

Health

Turning Barbershops into Telehealth Centers

Craig Settles  |  Op-Ed  |  Government Technology

In urban neighborhoods, where Internet service and health care can be hard to access, a novel pilot project uses local barbershops and salons as wireless hubs and hypertension screening centers. Dec 2019, barbershops and hair salons in urban and rural communities across five cities will connect USB blood pressure cuffs to telehealth platforms via community networks to attack hypertension, the leading cause of strokes. By adding telehealth capabilities to the screening process, customers potentially can access educational content about stroke and heart attack prevention, hypertension and wellness programs. During the pilot, customers can download free telehealth software that enables them to set up home video consults with their own doctors. 

Ron Deus is CEO of NetX, a regional wireless Internet service provider (ISP) in Cleveland (OH). “What happens in the suburban and urban areas amounts to redlining,” said Deus. “Incumbents’ buildouts, upgrades and adoption efforts happen in the most profitable areas first. Areas just a mile or two away become digital deserts. A lot of incumbents are shareholder driven, so their first concerns are their profits and cherry-picking.” As Internet network hubs, urban barbershops are less costly to set up than in rural areas, and they are good locations for telehealth pilots. They are also great when it comes to word-of-mouth marketing. What’s needed is the right kind of grant to cover both broadband and telehealth for these urban locations.

[Craig Settles assists cities and co-ops with business planning for broadband and telehealth.]

Research

Striking Tech Findings From 2019

John Gramlich  |  Research  |  Pew Research Center

Every year, Pew Research Center publishes hundreds of reports, blog posts, digital essays and other studies on a wide range of topics. At the end of each year, we compile a list of some of our most noteworthy findings. These are a few striking findings related to tech policy:

  • A majority of Americans do not think it is possible to go about daily life without corporate and government entities collecting information about them. Americans widely believe at least some of their online and offline activities are being tracked and monitored by companies and the government. It is such a common condition of modern life, in fact, that roughly six-in-ten US adults say they don’t think it is possible to go through daily life without having data collected about them by companies (62% say this) or the government (63%).
  • US newspaper circulation has fallen to its lowest level since at least 1940, the earliest year with available data. Total daily newspaper circulation – print and digital combined – was an estimated 28.6 million for weekday and 30.8 million for Sunday in 2018. Those numbers were down 8% and 9%, respectively, from the previous year and are now below their lowest recorded levels (though weekday circulation first passed this threshold in 2013).
  • Despite the economic troubles facing the news industry, about seven-in-ten Americans (71%) believe their local news media organizations are doing well financially. This belief persists even though only 14% of US adults say they personally have paid for local news within the past year, whether through subscriptions, donations or memberships. When asked why they don’t pay for local news, around half of non-payers (49%) point to the widespread availability of free content.
  • The most active 10% of adult Twitter users in the US produce 80% of all tweets sent by these users.
  • A single person watching YouTube videos for eight hours a day with no breaks or days off would need more than 16 years to watch all the content posted by just the most popular channels on the platform during a single week. 

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2019. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2019