Daily Digest 12/14/2020 (Charley Frank Pride | David John Moore Cornwell)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Broadband/Internet

The Broadband Mapping Flaw that's Harming Education and Healthcare  |  Read below  |  Rachelle Chong, Larry Irving  |  Op-Ed  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Reforming funding of universal access to telecommunications and broadband services: Approaches for the new decade  |  Read below  |  Victor Glass, Timothy Tardiff  |  Research  |  Telecommunications Policy
Analysis: RDOF Analysis Reveals Surprises and Growing Controversy  |  telecompetitor
Some Early Thoughts on RDOF Results  |  NTCA-The Rural Broadband Association
USDA Invests $12 Million in High-Speed Broadband in Rural Louisiana  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Department of Agriculture
Broadband/Internet Availability Survey Report  |  Read below  |  Research  |  NTCA-The Rural Broadband Association
Massive Gigabit “Coverage” Increase Highlights How Unreliable FCC Broadband Data Can Be  |  Read below  |  Tyler Cooper  |  Analysis  |  BroadbandNow
Maryland needs better broadband — everywhere  |  Read below  |  State Delegate Brooke Lierman (D-Baltimore)  |  Op-Ed  |  Washington Post
Cuyahoga County, Ohio, seeks more projects, partnerships to close digital divide  |  Read below  |  Emily Bamforth  |  Cleveland.com
North Carolina legislative leaders, governor reach $30 million rural broadband funding deal  |  WNCN
Overcome Being Overwhelmed: Building a Path to Connectivity in All Communities  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Connected Nation
California Legislation to Make Significant Investments in Public Broadband  |  Electronic Frontier Foundation
Hanover County (VA) Board of Supervisors approves plan to increase countywide access to broadband connection  |  Richmond Times-Dispatch
Hillsboro launches HiLight, aspiring to build Oregon’s largest city-run internet service  |  Oregonian, The

Wireless

Verizon Indoor 5G Launched, Setting Stage for Private 5G  |  telecompetitor

Platforms

Commissioner O'Rielly: People 'Missing the Debate' on Section 230  |  Read below  |  Steven Overly  |  Politico
FCC Commissioner Carr urges lame-duck agency action to clip Section 230  |  Read below  |  Ina Fried  |  Axios
The ‘app store’ before there was an App Store wants to liberate your iPhone … again  |  Read below  |  Reed Albergotti  |  Washington Post
California Seeks to Join Justice Department Antitrust Case Against Google  |  Wall Street Journal
Why can’t the social networks stop fake accounts?  |  New York Times
Social media continue to be important political outlets for Black Americans  |  Pew Research Center
Tim Wu: Facebook Cannot Buy Its Way Out of Competition  |  New York Times

Education

As Districts Return to Remote Learning, Are They Any Better Prepared?  |  EdSurge

Journalism

Amanda Bennett: I was Voice of America’s director. Trump’s latest pick to run the organization is dangerous.  |  Washington Post

Content/Television

Hollywood Shock Turns to Full-Blown Backlash After WarnerMedia Streaming Move  |  Wrap, The
Christopher Nolan Says Warner Bros.' Shift To Streaming New Movies 'A Great Danger'  |  National Public Radio
Where Does Hulu Fit in Disney’s Super-Size Streaming Strategy?  |  Wrap, The
119 Cable Channels Ranked by 2020 Viewership  |  Wrap, The

Security

Russian government hackers are behind broad espionage campaign that compromised US agencies, including Treasury and Commerce  |  Washington Post

Privacy

Privacy Policy and the Biden Presidency: A Promising Outlook?  |  Government Technology
Sen. Klobuchar, spooked by Amazon Halo, asks for new health-tracker privacy protections  |  Washington Post

Policymakers

Filing Facebook Lawsuit Is Career-Defining Act for FTC Chairman Simon  |  Wall Street Journal
FTC suffering a cash crunch as it prepares to battle Facebook  |  Politico

Stories From Abroad

Poor broadband can knock £40k off average London home: study  |  City AM
Big Tech Turns Its Lobbyists Loose on Europe, Alarming Regulators  |  New York Times
Today's Top Stories

Broadband/Internet

The Broadband Mapping Flaw that's Harming Education and Healthcare

Rachelle Chong, Larry Irving  |  Op-Ed  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Dora the Explorer knew that maps were important to find one’s way. Unfortunately, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is still learning that lesson, particularly when it comes to broadband for the nation’s schools, libraries, healthcare providers, and other community anchor institutions. It’s no secret that the FCC’s current broadband maps are flawed. The existing maps rely on industry-reported data that overstates broadband availability and prevents communities from obtaining broadband funding. Consequently, many rural, remote, and Tribal communities sit on the wrong side of the digital divide, where they can’t access essential broadband-enabled services such as remote learning and telehealth. More accurate broadband maps will help the FCC understand where, exactly, these communities lie and enable better funding decisions. The Schools, Health & Libraries Broadband (SHLB) Coalition recently filed comments with the FCC and an additional ex parte letter urging the FCC to include anchor institutions in the maps, but the FCC’s response has been non-committal so far. The FCC’s reluctance is perhaps rooted in old fashioned regulatory rules dating back to the days of the Ma Bell monopoly. Congress should encourage the FCC to look to the future by declining to appropriate funding for the Broadband DATA Act until the commission agrees to map anchor institutions.

[Rachelle Chong is the Vice Chair of the SHLB Coalition Board of Directors and a former FCC Commissioner. Larry Irving sits on the SHLB Coalition Board of Directors and is the former Administrator of the National Telecommunications and Information Administration.]

Reforming funding of universal access to telecommunications and broadband services: Approaches for the new decade

Victor Glass, Timothy Tardiff  |  Research  |  Telecommunications Policy

The Federal Communications Commission universal service support fund's revenue base has been shrinking while the payouts have risen. As a result, the contribution factor, an ad valorem tax on the revenue base, rose from 16.7% in 2017 to 21.2% in 2020. We propose two solutions to the funding problem: A near-term funding reform proposal that widens the revenue base by replacing the current definition of assessable services (interstate and international) with a more inclusive definition of all communication services that have a telecommunications component. A longer-term strategy is to expand the revenue base to include basic utility network revenues. This proposal assumes that it is cost effective to develop one physical broadband network (landline and wireless) in high-cost areas and use the latest software-defined technologies to allow utilities to either split the physical network's functionalities into independent or cooperative virtual networks.

USDA Invests $12 Million in High-Speed Broadband in Rural Louisiana

Press Release  |  Department of Agriculture

The United States Department of Agriculture is investing approximately $12 million to provide broadband service in unserved and underserved rural areas in Louisiana. Star Telephone Company Inc. will use a $6.1 million ReConnect grant, and a $6.1 million Reconnect loan to deploy a fiber-to-premises network. This high-speed broadband network will connect 3,857 people, 69 businesses, 149 farms, five educational facilities and two essential community facilities in Rapides, Concordia, Pointe Coupee, Avoyelles and Evangeline parishes in Louisiana.

Broadband/Internet Availability Survey Report

To gauge the deployment rates of advanced services by its member companies, for nearly two decades NTCA–The Rural Broadband Association (NTCA) has conducted its Broadband/Internet Availability Survey. This latest broadband survey is a follow-up to similar surveys conducted in recent years by NTCA and seeks to build upon the results of those surveys. This year’s survey asked about technologies used to provide broadband service in ILEC service areas, broadband availability and subscription rates, anchor institutions, fixed wireless broadband services, competitive broadband services, mobile voice and broadband data service, competition/marketing, fiber deployment, the impact of COVID-19 on customer payments, internet backbone and middle mile connections, VoIP, and video service. The average service area identified by respondents is approximately 2,063 square miles. Nearly half (49.5%) report having a service area of less than 500 square miles, while just over one-quarter (25.8%) have a service area between 500-1,999 square miles, and a proportion slightly smaller (24.7%) have a service area of 2,000 square miles or larger. Respondents indicated that they use a variety of platforms within their respective service areas to provide broadband service to their customers. On average, seven in 10 (69.9%) serviceable locations are served by fiber to the home (FTTH) in 2020, while an average of 21.2% are served via copper loops. Fiber to the node (FTTN) is used to serve an average of 5.8% serviceable locations, cable modems 1.4%, unlicensed fixed wireless 1.3% and licensed fixed wireless 0.5%. On average, respondents indicated the following percentage of their customer base can receive maximum downstream speeds of:

  • Greater than/equal to 1 Gig: 45.1%
  • Greater than/equal to 100 Mbps but less than 1 Gig: 22.7%
  • Greater than/equal to 25 Mbps but less than 100 Mbps: 12.6%
  • Greater than/equal to 10 Mbps but less than 25 Mbps: 12.1%
  • Greater than/equal to 4 Mbps but less than 10 Mbps: 5.3%
  • Greater than/equal to 200 kbps but less than 4 Mbps: 2.3%

Respondents’ customers subscribe to the following maximum downstream speeds:

  • 7.9% subscribe to speeds greater than/equal to 1 Gig.
  • 20.2% subscribe to greater than/equal to 100 Mbps but less than 1 Gig.
  • 35.8% subscribe to greater than/equal to 25 Mbps but less than 100 Mbps.
  • 21.3% subscribe to greater than/equal to 10 Mbps but less than 25 Mbps.
  • 10.5% subscribe greater than/equal to 4 Mbps but less than 10 Mbps.
  • 4.3% subscribe to service greater than/equal to 200 kbps but less than 4 Mbps.

Massive Gigabit “Coverage” Increase Highlights How Unreliable FCC Broadband Data Can Be

Tyler Cooper  |  Analysis  |  BroadbandNow

Progress on gigabit deployment in the US has been greatly exaggerated. This is true for the state of the internet in general. However, the gigabit landscape is a subsection worth examining more closely, as it is the connectivity threshold that will be required to solve the speed and functionality divides of the near future. The Federal Communications Commission claims that gigabit availability has ballooned from 4% in 2016 to 84% in 2020. Our own estimates, however, show that gigabit plan access has actually gone from 2.4% in the same year to 56% in 2020.

  • According to the FCC, gigabit internet availability has seen explosive growth over the past four years, rising from just 4% in 2016 to over 84% in 2020. 
  • These numbers aren’t reflective of consumer reality, however, with only 56% of Americans having an active gigabit plan in their zip code in 2020 (even this number is likely overstated). 
  • We manually checked 75 addresses in zip codes where the FCC shows gigabit coverage, but BroadbandNow data shows that there is not an internet plan sold at that speed.  We checked these addresses by calling internet service providers and asking if gigabit service was available.  In all 75 cases, none of them had a gigabit service available.
  • In areas where gigabit service is available, pricing has stabilized somewhat: median price for specific plans has dropped by 27%, from $109.00 in 2016 to $79.99 today. 
  • In 2016, 115 providers were servicing residents in 32 states. In 2020, 479 providers now claim gigabit coverage to areas in all 50 states. 

Maryland needs better broadband — everywhere

State Delegate Brooke Lierman (D-Baltimore)  |  Op-Ed  |  Washington Post

During a Thanksgiving like no other, millions of Americans chose to forgo holiday travel and instead use family video calls to get as close as safely possible to loved ones. Unfortunately, this connection was not an option for many Maryland families because of a pervasive and growing digital divide in our state — one of many added challenges facing disconnected Marylanders this year. This digital divide isn’t only about staying connected to loved ones; it is also the difference between a student keeping pace with classmates or missing out entirely. This inequitable access means some Marylanders can safely participate in remote doctors’ visits while others suffer without medical care — until they end up in emergency rooms. It means that businesses cannot launch in disconnected areas of the state, as it is nearly unthinkable in this day to start a business without reliable, affordable Internet. For these and many other reasons, sustaining and building thriving local economies and healthy communities mean ensuring every Marylander has access to high-speed Internet. Gov. Larry Hogan (R-MD) created the Office of Rural Broadband in 2017, and though it has done important work, more support and coordination are needed. The problems are bigger than just those affecting our rural jurisdictions. Increased deployment of broadband Internet will improve long-term quality of life for all Marylanders and will ensure that we remain economically competitive — locally and globally. Because this is a statewide problem, we need a statewide office that will pull together private and public partners, agencies and county governments to identify the gaps and implement affordable, reliable, high-speed access for all.

[Brooke Lierman, a Democrat, represents Baltimore in the Maryland House of Delegates]

Cuyahoga County, Ohio, seeks more projects, partnerships to close digital divide

Emily Bamforth  |  Cleveland.com

Cuyahoga County (OH) is seeking more partnerships and projects to help close the digital divide, planning for a long-term solution to lack of internet access in the county. The county issued a “request for information,” which is due by Jan. 15. The goal is to find developed projects or vendors who might be able to offer new products, discounted service options and free or innovative solutions to Wi-Fi or technology issues. This is just so the county can assess different approaches it might take to address the problem, not necessarily enter a partnership or hire these vendors. The request explains that officials may look at proposals and decide to offer a more detailed request, “cancel, or delay plans for this initiative, or choose another direction that is deemed in the community’s best interest.”

Overcome Being Overwhelmed: Building a Path to Connectivity in All Communities

Press Release  |  Connected Nation

We know it’s tough right now. But, especially so, for local community leaders who must wear multiple hats and try to solve the connectivity problem for everyone. “Most of us are a bit overwhelmed and getting caught up with back-to-back-to-back video calls,” said Tom Stephenson, Community Technology Advisor, Connected Nation. “On more than one occasion, I’ve been on a regional or community call when one of the leaders forgets which meeting they are in and starts discussing a totally different subject matter out of the blue. They forget what group they are talking to simply because they’re juggling so much.” For every community—whether urban or rural—ensuring internet connectivity for everyone is a challenge many local leaders have been chipping away at for years. However, when the pandemic forced most of us home, there was an urgency placed on finding ways to connect more families, businesses, and community organizations as soon as possible. Connected Nation, through its Connected Community Engagement Program, has worked with nearly 400 communities and surveyed more than 30,000 individuals nationwide to do one thing—develop Technology Action Plans that are specific to a community or region’s needs. The Connected program’s Technology Action Plans leverage input and data provided by residents, businesses, community organizations, and others to identify problem areas and solutions for expanding high-speed internet (broadband) access a community, county, or region.

Platforms

Commissioner O'Rielly: People 'Missing the Debate' on Section 230

Steven Overly  |  Politico

Outgoing-Federal Communications Commissioner Michael O’Rielly participated in his final FCC meeting Dec 10 before Nathan Simington is sworn in to take his seat as one of the agency’s Republican commissioners. Although there were many appreciative send-offs, the departing commissioner also touched on the hot-button tech issue that likely led to President Donald Trump killing his renomination this past summer: Section 230. Commissioner O’Rielly questioned whether recent attacks on social media liability protections are being made in good faith. “A lot of the things people are talking about today, that they want to see changed under 230, are protected by the First Amendment, and therefore I think that people are missing the debate, or intentionally missing the debate,” he told reporters after the meeting. “I’m skeptical of the commission’s authority and I’m worried. And I want to know the implications for decisions as they reflect on the First Amendment.” Fellow GOP Commissioner Brendan Carr told reporters that, ahead of Inauguration Day, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai should still move forward to “bring clarity” and “guidance” to questions around Section 230 as the Trump administration requested. He also said the FCC can do so in a way “that doesn’t require a lengthy process.” But the debate has been mired in “shadow boxing” and “straw men,” Commissioner Carr added, stressing that he has no interest in the agency becoming the government “speech police,” as his Democratic colleagues warned. (He says his focus is on when liability protections apply for taking down content.) He cited bipartisan attention to these issues in Congress and expressed hope that any FCC action could have a “bipartisan and enduring consensus.”

FCC Commissioner Carr urges lame-duck agency action to clip Section 230

Ina Fried  |  Axios

Federal Communications Commissioner Brendan Carr suggested that the agency should jam through rules to limit tech's liability shield before President Donald Trump leaves office. Commissioner Carr told reporters he believes the FCC could avoid a "lengthy process" for writing rules to curb Section 230's reach, noting a path for quickly instituting "interpretive rules" outlined on Twitter by tech policy lawyer Berin Szóka, who opposes the idea and believes it wouldn't stand up in court. Carr's idea would be another path to damaging Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a foundational law for the modern internet, after Trump's attempt to repeal it via must-pass defense legislation stalled out.

The ‘app store’ before there was an App Store wants to liberate your iPhone … again

Reed Albergotti  |  Washington Post

A new lawsuit brought by one of Apple’s oldest foes seeks to force the iPhone maker to allow alternatives to the App Store, the latest in a growing number of cases that aim to curb the tech giant’s power. The lawsuit was filed by the maker of Cydia, a once-popular app store for the iPhone that launched in 2007, before Apple created its own version. The lawsuit alleges that Apple used anti-competitive means to nearly destroy Cydia, clearing the way for the App Store, which Cydia’s attorneys say has a monopoly over software distribution on iOS, Apple’s mobile operating system. The lawsuit was filed in federal court in Northern California and Cydia is represented by Quinn Emanuel Urquhart and Sullivan.

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2020. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2019