July 2016

Clinton Puts Forth a Tech Plan. Trump Doesn’t.

[Commentary] Presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton unveiled her Technology & Innovation Agenda this week. Published on her website June 28, Clinton’s 14-page tech plan provides a detailed and ambitious policy agenda that covers a wide swath of critical telecom policy issues. The plan is organized around five major categories: the Economy, Digital Infrastructure, Advancing US Global Leadership, Privacy, and Smart Government. Below we examine the plan through our lens: broadband access, adoption, and use. Clinton’s tech plan is filled with so many proposals and goals that the best thing to do is just read it for yourself. Seriously. If you’re reading this article, you probably care about Internet adoption or net neutrality, spectrum policy or municipal broadband, privacy or diversifying the tech workforce. Her plan covers all of that. But, if you’re still reading this because you want the Reader’s Digest version, here goes.

Tech industry wants Trump agenda

The tech industry is pressing Donald Trump to “get into the game” after Hillary Clinton released a wide-ranging platform that touched on internet connectivity, cybersecurity and computer science education. Industry officials generally applauded Clinton’s agenda as hitting many of their top priorities. Now they want to hear from Trump, the presumptive Republican nominee.

Republicans on Capitol Hill said it is important for candidates to detail their platforms early, but said the decision is Trump’s to make. Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-SD) said he expects Trump to release something on tech policy before the general election debates begin, noting the presumptive nominee's business background and social media savvy. “I think both candidates are going to be vying on some of these issues for the so-called tech vote, and whether it happens now or some point in the future, I’m sure that Donald Trump will also have an agenda that will compete for the support of the tech community,” said Chairman Thune, a major voice on tech issues. A spokesperson for Trump’s campaign did not respond to a question about the campaign’s plans.

Trump appears to be lacking support in the tech industry heading into the general election, after the candidate clashed with several major companies during the Republican primaries.

Better Internet policy needed for minority communities

[Commentary] The future of a free, open, and affordable internet lies in the hands of our next president. The next four years will be crucial to developing the infrastructure and policies that shape the experience of Americans online - and determine if they can participate at all. If the internet is to serve the needs of all Americans, we can't afford to waste this opportunity. If we are to build a country that is equitable and just, where economic opportunity is available to all, and where diverse voices have an equal say in our politics, our nation's internet policy must reflect these values as well. Yet, for many Americans, especially people of color, access is out of reach. The digital divide is real, and filling in the gaps is crucial to prosperity not only for individuals, but for the country as a whole.

As people of color become a larger proportion of our population, we need to make sure we arm these future leaders with the basic tools that will help them achieve their goals and give back to their neighbors. The future of education, our economy, and civic engagement depend on ensuring that as many Americans as possible have access to affordable high-speed internet. If we are to build equitable education systems and promote economic opportunity for all, we need policies that will not only increase high-speed internet access, but make sure that it is affordable as well. Yet, as we work to expand access, we also need to make sure that we stay true to the principles that have made the internet such a powerful tool.

A free and open internet creates more opportunities for diverse voices to organize, to share our stories and to transform culture, attitudes and beliefs about Latinos and other groups that have faced discrimination from mainstream American culture. In these ways, an affordable and open internet helps to create a more inclusive and accepting society, to break down barriers and to counteract fear and hate. Public policy should promote these values and ensure that the diversity of our nation is reflected in our media.

[González is executive vice president and general counsel for the National Hispanic Media Coalition]

Pillars of Black Media, Once Vibrant, Now Fighting for Survival

Traditional media companies have struggled for years to adapt to a digital world, but the pressure on black-owned media has been even more acute. Many are smaller and lack the financial resources to compete in an increasingly consolidated media landscape. Advertisers have turned away from black-oriented media, owners say, under the belief that they can now reach minorities in other ways. Since well before the Civil War, publications and, more recently, radio and television stations owned and operated by African-Americans have provided an important counterweight to mass market media, simultaneously celebrating and shaping black culture — from politics and government to fashion and music. But as financial resources dwindle, black-owned media companies are struggling to maintain their presence.

Setting Sights on the Forward Auction

We have now established the clearing cost for repurposing 126 MHz of licensed and unlicensed spectrum for wireless data use. The next step in this stage is to prepare bidders for their chance to acquire the 100 MHz of licensed spectrum in the forward auction. Here’s what comes next.

  1. Bidder Qualification: Upfront payments – the refundable down payments that applicants make in order to establish their bidding eligibility for the auction – are due today at 5pm ET. Once we’ve validated which applicants have made payments, we will release a list of qualified bidders in mid-July.
  2. Bidder Education: Shortly we will release a user guide for the forward auction bidding system and an online tutorial. Qualified bidders will then be able to participate in an extensive bidder training program, which will include the first-ever FCC “practice auction” and a mock auction shortly before the bidding rounds begin.
  3. Clock Bidding: After the mock auction concludes, clock bidding will begin. Like the reverse auction, each round will offer bidders an incremental change in price for the licenses on which they’re bidding. If forward auction proceeds are sufficient to satisfy the “final stage rule” then the auction can close at the current clearing target; if not, then the auction is designed to run additional stages to match supply and demand. Forward auction bidders have the largest possible nationwide supply of low-band spectrum available to them, and this summer they will have the opportunity to bid on it. The end result of the auction will be the repurposing of as much spectrum for wireless broadband use as the market demands. We look forward to working with the bidders as they prepare.

[Epstein is Chair of the FCC’s Incentive Auction Task Force; Symons is Vice-Chair]