August 2015

Public Knowledge Joins Letter Urging White House to Open Up Federally Funded Educational Resources

Public Knowledge, along with a broad coalition of more than 80 education, library, technology, public interest, and legal organizations, called on the White House to take administrative action to ensure federally funded educational materials are made available as Open Education Resources (OER) that are free to use, share, and improve. The call comes in response to the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy’s (OSTP) request for ideas to strengthen the US Open Government National Action Plan. The executive action envisioned by the coalition would build upon the Administration’s strong leadership in advancing public access to publicly funded resources with a strong Executive Branch-wide policy for the open licensing of educational, training, and instructional materials created with federal funds. The signatories have outlined five core principles for Administration policy on this issue:

  1. Adopt a broad definition of educational materials
  2. Provide free access via the Internet
  3. Create conditions for resources that enable reuse
  4. Require prompt implementation
  5. Regular reporting of progress and results

Chris Lewis, Vice President of Government Affairs at Public Knowledge, said “There’s no question that we’re living in the digital era. We’re now at a critical point where publicly funded educational resources are available online, but can’t be viewed by the very public that pays for them. We’re asking the Administration to make federally funded educational materials available as Open Education Resources that are free to use, share and improve. This way all Americans have the opportunity to engage with the educational materials they themselves funded.”

danah boyd To Deliver 33rd Annual Everett C Parker Lecture, Joseph Torres and Wally Bowen to be Honored

danah boyd, named by Fortune magazine in 2010 as “the smartest academic in tech,” will deliver the 33rd annual Everett C. Parker Ethics in Telecommunications Lecture. Joseph Torres and Wally Bowen will be honored at the 2015 Parker Lecture and Breakfast. The event, organized by the United Church of Christ’s media justice ministry, the Office of Communication, Inc., will be held at 8 am ET on Tuesday, Oct. 20, at First Congregational United Church of Christ, 945 G St. NW, Washington, DC.

Torres will receive the Everett C. Parker Award, given in recognition of an individual whose work embodies the principles and values of the public interest in telecommunications and the media. Wally Bowen, a nationally-known advocate for local self-reliance via local ownership of media infrastructure, will receive the Donald H. McGannon Award. 2015's McGannon award is being given in recognition of Wally’s dedication to bringing modern telecommunications to low-income people in rural areas.

Privacy Protests About Senate Cybersecurity Bill Grow Louder

Cybersecurity legislation is on the Senate floor, but widespread worry over the security of Americans’ personal information threatens the likelihood of the bill passing before the August recess. Another question floating around among cybersecurity experts is more fundamental -- will the bill actually improve computer security? The Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act (S. 754) is already vocally opposed by Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR), who was the only member of the Senate Intelligence Committee to vote against the bill as it ultimately passed the panel 14-1. Sen Wyden is not alone in voicing these concerns. Both Democrats and Republicans in the Senate, along with the Department of Homeland Security, harbor growing apprehensions.

Keith Chu, Sen Wyden’s press secretary, said that there is a “strong and significant number” of senators from both parties who want to see amendments to the bill. “Clearly there are members on both sides of the aisle who think there need to be a number of amendments,” he said. Sen Wyden reiterated his worries that the bill “collects enormous amounts of personal information on Americans and has very little, if anything, to protect the privacy of the American people.” Sen Al Franken (D-MN) has also been outspoken regarding privacy and wants to see the introduction of amendments to address the concerns. He believes it’s crucial that senators have a real opportunity to offer amendments, specifically ones that would address the standards for the removal of unnecessary personal information and the scope of the bill’s authorizations, according to a Sen Franken aide.

Stolen Consumer Data Is a Smaller Problem Than It Seems

At Target, 40 million customers had their credit card information exposed to hackers. At JPMorgan Chase, personal details associated with 80 million accounts were leaked. In July, a hacker gained access to 4.5 million records from the University of California, Los Angeles, health system. Enormous numbers like these can make it feel as if we’re living through an epidemic of data breaches, in which no one’s bank account or credit card is safe. But the actual effect on consumers is quite different from what the headlines suggest. Only a tiny number of people exposed by leaks end up paying any costs, and for the rare victims who do, the average cost has actually been falling steadily. How could that be?

For starters, several laws protect consumers from bearing almost any financial losses related to hackers (though not the headaches of having to enter new credit card numbers into Amazon and elsewhere). Instead, banks and merchants, like Target, must bear the cost. But even their losses have been dropping in recent years, as data security experts have learned new strategies to prevent intrusions from turning into theft. It’s true that data breaches, particularly those in which Social Security numbers are compromised, can lead to a more devastating sort of identity theft, in which criminals open new financial accounts in a person’s name and do damage that can take years and a lot of work to clean up. But consumers are almost never on the hook for financial losses in these sorts of episodes, which, by the way, have also been on the decline.

Baltimore faced cyberattacks amid chaos and unrest on the streets

As Baltimore (MD) remained under curfew after riots over Freddie Gray's death, a cyberattack knocked out the city's website while hackers who sympathized with protesters on the streets threatened to target the government's computer systems, according to newly released documents. The behind-the-scenes cyberbattle shut down the website baltimorecity.gov for at least 16 hours, according to a situation report dated May 1. The site, which provides information on government services, updated citizens on the citywide curfew at the time. "Not sure when site will be up and running. Need to set up alternatives," the report stated.

E-mails and other documents give new insights into the attack as well as a campaign that targeted police and city databases and claimed to be affiliated with Anonymous, an international network of activist hackers. The documents also detail efforts to combat the hackers by information technology experts, including city and state officials, a special detachment of National Guard troops, and a Baltimore security company that witnessed activity online and offered its services. Computer security analysts said that activist groups frequently launch hacking campaigns amid civil turmoil -- and that government officials often find themselves ill-equipped to respond. Such attacks can be minor nuisances that knock out websites for short periods or major security breaches that put troves of sensitive data at risk and disrupt access to government services.

Comcast is doubling the speed of its low-cost Internet plans

Comcast is rolling out a few upgrades to its Internet program for low-income consumers, doubling download speeds and, for the first time, targeting senior citizens under a Florida-based pilot project. The $10-a-month program, Internet Essentials, will be getting a free speed bump from 5 megabits per second to 10 Mbps, which is fast enough to support multiple video streams simultaneously. That's good news for poorer Americans who increasingly rely on the Web to do homework, find jobs and use government services. Comcast is also expanding access to Internet Essentials.

Eligibility for Internet Essentials used to be dictated by whether households had a child who qualified for free or reduced-price school lunches, or who merely attended a school where 70 percent of the school qualified for meal subsidies. Now, Comcast is lowering that 70 percent threshold to 50 percent to make it easier for more families to qualify for Internet Essentials. And its pilot project in West Palm Beach (FL) will give older Americans -- who, according to the Pew Research Center, remain disproportionately unconnected from the Web -- access to Internet Essentials, too. So far Comcast hasn't laid out how it will evaluate this pilot project, over what time period, or even how it will determine eligibility for seniors. Proof of eligibility could be Medicaid or Medicare, for instance. Although some older Americans already likely benefit from Internet Essentials by living in the same household as those eligible school-aged children, the program expansion would give other seniors the ability to sign up for low-cost Internet. Roughly 500,000 households have signed up for Internet Essentials so far, up from 350,000 a year ago.

Facebook’s Copyright Violation Problem -- Which May Not Be a Problem for Facebook at All

In 2006, Google bought YouTube and over time built out a “Content ID” system -- part software, part business rules -- that automated much of the process of copyright violations. It gives copyright owners the opportunity to take unauthorized clips down with a couple of keystrokes -- or make money from them via advertising. Facebook says it is working on its own system. But in the meantime it appears to be operating the way YouTube did in 2005 -- takedowns happen slowly, one at a time, if they happen at all.

Ten years ago, this seemed to be a very pressing issue for both YouTube and the entertainment industry. Right now, though, there doesn’t seem to be the same angst. Industry sources say Facebook is indeed “actively exploring further solutions” for this. They believe Facebook has already built out the basic tools it will need to police copyright infringement more robustly and to automate takedowns. And they believe Facebook is now working on the other part of the equation -- creating a set of business rules that allow copyright owners to leave their stuff up on the site and share the ad revenue the clips create. But it’s a little odd that Facebook, which is chock full of really smart people, is only getting around to this now, after methodically building out a video product for the last year-plus.

Sprint Falls to No. 4 Among Wireless Carriers by Number of Subscribers

Sprint became the smallest of the four major US wireless carriers last quarter, as it gained 675,000 customers compared to more than two million customers for T-Mobile US. That left Sprint with 57.7 million subscribers, compared to 58.9 million subscribers for T-Mobile. Some thought the changeover would happen earlier in 2015, but strong prepaid gains helped keep Sprint narrowly ahead of T-Mobile in the first quarter. Still, there was a fair bit of good news in Sprint’s report.

The company raised its outlook for the fiscal year, saying it now expects earnings before income, taxes and other items to be between $7.2 billion and $7.6 billion, as compared to a prior forecast of $6.5 billion to $6.9 billion in such income. Sprint also neared its goal of turning positive in terms of core smartphone subscribers, losing just 12,000 such customers in the quarter, as compared to the several hundred thousand or millions that it had been ceding in prior quarters. The company said it gained postpaid smartphone customers in both May and June. The company also did better at holding on to existing customers, with a record low churn rate of 1.56 percent, compared to more than 2 percent a year earlier. Meanwhile, the company posted another quarterly loss, but the $20 million loss amounted to just a penny per share, far narrower than the eight-cent loss that analysts had been expecting. Its net operating revenue of $8 billion was down 9 percent from the prior year as more customers shifted to buying their smartphones in monthly installments.

Texting Parents to get Kids Ready 4K!

[Commentary] Over the past few years, a growing number of early education programs focused on building literacy skills are seeking to address this issue at an early age with the help of technological tools. Ready 4K! is one program that shows evidence of succeeding at closing the word gap. The program focuses on building parent knowledge by sending text messages explaining how to help build children’s literacy skills. The program primarily promotes early literacy and language, but also is piloting texts that target other early learning skills, such as socioemotional learning and early math.

In 2013, Ben York and Susanna Loeb of Stanford University piloted Ready 4K! in the San Francisco Unified School District to help close the word gap between affluent and low-income children. The text messaging program targeted low-income families with four-year-old children. Through the use of a randomized controlled trial, the program showed significant gains between families that had received the targeted early literacy text messages and those that received the placebo messages that, for instance, may have just alerted parents about vaccination requirements for kindergarten. Children who received the early literacy text messages gained an additional two to three months of learning in some areas.

Civic design at scale: Why I joined the US Digital Service

[Commentary] If you think about it, government is a massive, continuous service design project. Laws design the scope and constraints of an experience. Agencies that carry out the laws create content, interactions, transactions  --  and they deliver it all on various channels, through hundreds of touch points. The crazy thing is  --  in spite of persistent efforts by many fantastic professionals in various corners of government over the last couple of decades  --  there hasn’t been an obvious and successful effort to put users, the constituents, at the heart of designing programs, systems, or services.

The decision to join the US Digital Service wasn’t an easy one. I had just gotten married and started the Center for Civic Design with Whitney Quesenbery. But the chance to practice, teach, promote, and support human-centered design in the federal government was just too great to pass up. Since I’ve been at the Digital Service, I’ve met hundreds of people in government who share my passion for usability, accessibility, and plain language. At US Citizenship and Immigration Services, I work with a spectacular group of people to build efficient and effective software for the people who are making decisions about who comes into this country. The complexity of modernizing this system is enormously challenging. But getting the chance to help the 1 million people a year who apply for a green card, or those who apply for naturalization so they can be United States citizens (and ultimately, voters), is exactly the kind of wicked problem I love working on.

[Dana Chisnell is a UX Researcher with the US Digital Service]