June 2010

The Four Pillars For Broadband Policy

The proposal to impose new and potentially sweeping regulations on broadband services under Title II of the Telecom Act represents a dangerous distraction from the Obama Administration's mission of universal broadband for all Americans. Such an unexpected sea change to established policy could deter new investment where it is needed most, potentially even exacerbating the persistent digital divide by pricing broadband beyond the reach of many low and moderate-income Americans. Instead of a regulatory blank check with the promise of forbearance, we need focused and narrowly-tailored legislation that empowers the FCC to advance core consensus elements of the national broadband plan, including initiatives to promote telemedicine, universal service reform and distance learning. In an effort to reduce uncertainty, maximize investment and achieve universal connectivity, we've put together Four Pillars for Broadband Policy. These are intended to offer a roadmap for advancing the Obama Administration's worthy goal of broadband access for every American. 1) Put Consumers First. 2) Promote Investment to Maximize Competition. 3) Minimize Regulatory Interventions to Reduce Investor Uncertainty. 4) Ensure Connectivity to All Communities.

FCC to Exempt Blog Comments from Title II Proceedings

The Federal Communications Commission has warned anybody who weighs in on an FCC blog about its plan to reclassify broadband under Title II regulation between June 10 and 17 will not have their comments taken into account in deciding how to put the final touches on the high-profile item.

That is because it would fall into the seven-day sunshine period before the FCC takes action on an item during which ex parte comments and meetings about it are off limits. Since the FCC decided it would start taking blog comments into account as official comments in its proceedings, it also has to discount them during that period. The FCC gave that notice June 10 in announcing what everybody already knew, that it would launch its inquiry into possible legal frameworks for broadband Internet regulation" in order to promote innovation and investment, protect and empower consumers, and bring the "benefits of broadband to all Americans."

Indian 4G Wireless Auction Brings in $5.5B

Indian authorities just wrapped up an auction for the 2.3 GHz spectrum to be used for broadband wireless access (BWA) services; it raised a total of $5.5 billion, roughly half of the $11 billion raised during the 3G auctions.

The biggest winner of the auction was Infotel, a privately held company that won licenses for all 22 regions, thus allowing it to become the largest wireless broadband provider in the country. Interestingly, none of the 3G spectrum owners have a nationwide footprint, which gives Infotel a big leg up in wireless broadband services. This discrepancy alone should raise eyebrows, but so far I've not seen it brought up in the Indian media. What's more intriguing is that right after the auction closed, Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Industries agreed to buy Infotel for $1 billion and said that it would pay the $2.74 billion Infotel would have had to fork over for the spectrum licenses. Mukesh's estranged brother, Anil Ambani, who owns Reliance Communications didn't win in the BWS auctions, though his company won many 3G licenses.

Google News Gives News Orgs a Chance to Stand Out

Many mainstream news organizations have long viewed Google News as a threat to their interests. But more recently, Google has been portrayed as sensitive to the health of the news media. Eric Schmidt, its chief executive, has worried openly about a world without high-quality journalism.

Now a recent experiment suggests that Google is at least considering taking another step to give increased exposure to several mainstream news publications. In an experimental new section on Google News called Editors Picks, discovered yesterday by the Nieman Journalism Lab, Google is offering a dozen or so news organizations the opportunity to prominently display their top links on the popular news page.

How Caffeine Is Giving Google a Turbo Boost

Google's revamped its search indexing methodology earlier this week. Google late June 9 announced that its search engine was now running on "Caffeine," meaning search results would show more recent information posted on the web as the technology behind it indexes results in seconds rather than weeks. But the allure of Caffeine isn't just the actual real-time search engine, it's the secret infrastructure sauce that Google uses to make a continuing real-time index of the entire web possible. That technology involves custom-built hardware and software that plenty of startups or business analytics companies would love to get their hands on.

Tribune's $43M executive bonus plan lambasted by trustee

The US Trustee overseeing Tribune Co.'s bankruptcy filed a preliminary objection to the Chicago media company's request for up to $43 million in 2010 bonuses, saying the company doesn't understand "shared sacrifice."

The trustee noted in the filing that if the additional compensation is granted, cash bonuses for executives and managers at Tribune -- which owns the Chicago Tribune and Los Angeles Times newspapers and several TV outlets -- will top $100 million. Tribune, known in the bankruptcy proceedings as the debtor, requested bonuses under four separate compensation programs. "While the debtors argue for 'shared sacrifice' in addressing collective bargaining issues with their unions, the debtors fail to understand what that concept means when it comes to compensating their management," Trustee Roberta DeAngelis wrote in the filing.

Has Technology Changed the Experience of Music?

[Commentary] Downloadable music files, online radio stations, streaming on-demand song libraries, iPods with mixes ... the music industry hasn't undergone a single tsunami. It's faced a onslaught of natural forces that changed the way we listen to music forever.

But are these technologies uprooting or upholding the experience of music, itself? It's easy to argue that technology's force has been disruptive. The music industry's profits have fallen by 60 percent in the last decade. You know why. When music was made of polyvinyl chloride (aka vinyl), it was hard to steal. Once it could be turned into a file, the price for many listeners fell to zero. Downloading and file sharing services from Napster to bittorrent create an ether market where the cost of gaining ownership of music is equal to the cost of an Internet connection. The impact on the music industry's bottom line is clear enough, but what about the impact on listeners? Half a century ago, the overwhelming choice was to buy and listen to whole albums. Today iTunes, the largest music store in the country, sells individual tracks that listeners can mix and mash in personal audio-collages. We, the listeners, now exert much more control than original artists over the narrative of our musical experience.

Smartphones Ripe for Privacy Violations

Malware targeting smartphones has been in the news a bit recently, thanks to some Windows snafus. But did you ever stop to think that the really scary thing about smartphones, according to security folk, is all your lovely data aboard 'em?

Professionals involved in defending the more typical desktop computing environment against viral and malware attacks actually aren't as worried about the mini computers we're all hauling around in our cramped jeans pockets. This is despite recent concerns about a Trojan app for Windows Mobile devices called 3D Anti Terrorist and a worm that infected jailbroken iPhones a little while ago. The smartphone platform is typically closed, and in Apple's case only approved apps are allowed onto the device (unless you jailbreak the phone) so there's pretty much zero chance you'll "catch" a virus that may spirit away your passwords or bank account details to a malicious Chinese or Zimbabwean criminal in the same way as happens for desktop PCs.

The future of cloud computing

Nearly 900 Internet experts and highly engaged users said they expect people who use the Internet will "live mostly in the cloud" by 2020, working primarily through the use of cyberspace-based applications on remote servers that we access through our networked devices.

This does not mean, however, that most think the desktop will disappear soon. The majority sees a hybrid model continuing where both cloud computing and desktop computing take on different functions. The Web-based survey, conducted by the Pew Research Center's Internet & American Life Project and the Imagining the Internet Center at Elon University, gathered opinions on 10 important issues from a select group of experts and the highly engaged Internet public. Results from this survey are being released in five major 2010 reports; this is the fourth.

Media Coverage of the Clergy Abuse Scandal

Newspaper coverage of the Catholic clergy sexual abuse scandal grew more intense this spring than at any time since 2002, and European newspapers devoted even more ink to the story than American papers did, according to a new study by the Pew Research Center.

The heavy coverage in Europe was a reversal of the pattern in 2002, when a Boston Globe series triggered an avalanche of reporting on sexual abuse by priests in the United States but relatively few stories appeared in the European press. In early 2010, by contrast, much of the reporting focused on sexual abuse of children in Europe, and English-language European newspapers published three times as many articles on the scandal as U.S. papers did, the new study finds. In addition, the media scrutiny this year zeroed in on the pope himself. During the six-week period from March 12 through April 27, Pope Benedict XVI was a major focus of more than half the stories on the scandal in the mainstream U.S. media, including print, radio, network television, cable TV and online news sources.