Originally published: November 15, 2012
Last updated: November 26, 2012 - 9:33pm
Verizon's claim that open Internet/network neutrality rules violate its free speech rights is "exactly backwards," a coalition of law professors and digital rights group Center for Democracy & Technology argue in court papers filed on November 15.
The Federal Communications Commission rules ban all broadband providers -- wireline as well as wireless -- from blocking sites or competing applications. The regulations, which took effect last year, also prohibit wireline providers from engaging in unreasonable discrimination. Verizon is arguing to the Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit that the rules should be vacated for several reasons, including that they violate the First Amendment by requiring it to transmit other companies' speech. The First Amendment generally prohibits the government from either censoring speech or forcing people to say something. But the advocates say in a friend-of-the-court brief that Verizon's argument misses the point. They say that neutrality rules don't infringe speech because the rules only apply when the company is acting as an intermediary for other parties' communications — not when the company speaks on its own behalf. The advocates add that the neutrality rules are similar to the common carrier rules that have long applied to telephone companies. "The rules do not restrict or compel anyone’s speech but instead protect everyone’s speech by requiring that it be transmitted without interference," the brief says.
- Former Commissioners Blast Verizon's Neutrality Stance
- Democrats troubled by Verizon's free speech argument in network neutrality case
- Lawyer: Verizon should be able to block websites
- Libertarians make the case: network neutrality is unconstitutional
- Verizon attack on Internet misguided
- Free Press Files in Support of FCC Comcast Order
- Can the FCC promote broadband competition, innovation, and investment? The courts and Congress to decide
- Verizon: Free Speech at Heart of Network Neutrality Case
- Consumer Federation of America: FCC Chairman Wheeler Proposal Appears Spot On
- ACLU and Facebook Defend the Right to 'Like'
- New regulatory battle brewing over ISP classification
- Verizon urges court to scrap network neutrality rules
- Groups Challenge FCC Wireless Auctions
- Verizon: Let Us Count the Ways FCC Is Wrong on Open Internet
- Legal battle over NSA surveillance grows