Daily Digest 11/4/2021 (Satellite Space Race)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Digital Equity

Six States Join the National Governors Association's Effort to Advance Digital Skill Development  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  National Governors Association

States/Local

Stimulus Funds Bolster Broadband Equity in Vermont and Virginia  |  Read below  |  Carl Smith  |  Governing
Northampton voters resoundingly pass municipal broadband ballot question, opening path to city-wide internet  |  MassLive

Wireless

Open Radio Access Networks: A Primer for Policymakers  |  Read below  |  Robert Atkinson, Doug Brake, Alexandra Bruer  |  Research  |  Information Technology & Innovation Foundation

Satellite

FCC Authorizes Boeing Broadband Satellite Constellation  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Press release
The latest space race is all about improving Internet access  |  Read below  |  Chris Velazco  |  Washington Post
BT and OneWeb fire up new LEO satellite connectivity deal  |  Read below  |  Bevin Fletcher  |  Fierce
The complicated promise of Amazon’s space internet  |  Vox
Starlink delays orders by years for unlucky customers who played with the site’s digital map  |  Vox

Platforms/Social Media

Here’s what happened when Facebook stopped protecting users — on purpose  |  Protocol
Farhad Manjoo: What Should We Actually Do About Facebook? I Asked the Experts.  |  New York Times
Microsoft’s Own Metaverse Is Coming, and It Will Have PowerPoint  |  Bloomberg
Facebook skirts Apple’s App Store fees with custom subscription links for creators  |  Vox

Privacy

House Commerce Republicans Unveil Strategy to Establish a National Privacy Standard  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  House Energy and Commerce Committee
Kristin Smith: Why We Need a Decentralized Internet  |  Morning Consult

Security

FCC Terminates China Telecom Services in the US  |  Read below  |  Press Release  |  Federal Communications Commission
Biden Administration Orders Federal Agencies to Fix Hundreds of Cyber Flaws  |  Wall Street Journal
Google Wants to Work With the Pentagon Again, Despite Employee Concerns  |  New York Times

Competition

FCC's Wireline Competition Bureau Extends Reply Deadline for Multi-Tenant Buildings Public Notice  |  Federal Communications Commission
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: The small agency that's threatening Big Tech  |  Axios
Why Facebook Is More Worried About Europe's Impending Online Regulations Than the US  |  Politico
Shira Ovide: The Strange Saga of Huawei  |  New York Times

Devices

The free laptop program built into President Biden's reconciliation plan  |  Read below  |  Makena Kelly  |  Vox

Climate

Help Make the Planet Greener by Getting Online  |  Read below  |  Martha Escutia, Sunne Wright McPeak  |  Op-Ed  |  Broadband Breakfast
How 10 fringe publishers fuel 69 percent of digital climate change denial  |  Center for Countering Digital Hate
Climate misinformation on Facebook ‘increasing substantially’, study says  |  Guardian, The

Policymakers

Senate Commerce Committee plans quick turnaround for FCC nominees  |  Read below  |  Benjamin Din  |  Politico
Remarks of FCC Commissioner Simington November 2021 APCO Emerging Technology Forum  |  Federal Communications Commission
Remarks of Rep Pallone at Subcommittee Markup of Communications and Technology Bills  |  House Energy and Commerce Committee

Industry/Company News

Jeff Moore: Wireless versus wireline competition is real  |  Fierce
Frontier adds a record 29 thousand fiber subscribers in Q3 as turnaround effort ramps  |  Fierce
SBA ups 2021 outlook as carrier activity ramps  |  Fierce
Today's Top Stories

Digital Equity

Six States Join the National Governors Association's Effort to Advance Digital Skill Development

Press Release  |  National Governors Association

Building upon the success of the first phase of the National Governors Association’s Workforce Innovation Network (NGA WIN), the NGA Center for Best Practices announced the addition of six new state grantees to the network. NGA WIN will award Hawaiʻi, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island up to $100,000 each and provide technical assistance to help state teams ensure all individuals have the digital skills needed to participate in work, education or training. The NGA Center will collaborate with NGA WIN advisors to deliver technical assistance and best practice resources to participating states through June 2022. Each state team — consisting of representatives from Governors’ offices, workforce development agencies and state workforce boards, and other state agencies — will work collaboratively toward a state vision for closing digital equity and workforce achievement gaps by advancing digital skill development. States will leverage tools such as the Digital Equity Scorecard – developed by NGA WIN advisors at the National Digital Inclusion Alliance, National Skills Coalition and Microsoft – to gather new data on skill gaps and develop plans to address gaps in priority industries, geographies and demographics.

States/Local

Stimulus Funds Bolster Broadband Equity in Vermont and Virginia

Carl Smith  |  Governing

Billions of federal dollars for broadband came with the stipulation that they benefit underserved populations. New projects that link last-mile access with affordability are paving the way for universal Internet service. The American Rescue Plan (ARP) included hundreds of billions of dollars for which broadband infrastructure was among the allowed uses. Infrastructure is not the only issue for those on the wrong side of the digital divide, however. Many who might have providers in their area cannot afford home service. In the months since ARP funds were approved, jurisdictions have embarked on projects to address both needs. “While state broadband grant programs have historically focused on expanding ‘last mile’ access in unserved areas, recent new federal spending — coupled with the flexibility with which those funds may be spent — have allowed states to address other aspects of the challenge of universal broadband, like making access affordable,” says Anna Read, a senior officer on the Broadband Access Initiative at The Pew Charitable Trusts. “This opportunity has led to some new and creative projects.” In Virginia, this includes providing free public Wi-Fi and developing municipal broadband networks. In Vermont, state officials have taken their own approach by establishing broadband cooperatives based on electric co-ops. The projects in Virginia and Vermont have been energized by stimulus funds, but they share a recognition that in this age, access is sufficiently important to deserve whatever support might be needed to sustain it over the long run.

Wireless

Open Radio Access Networks: A Primer for Policymakers

Robert Atkinson, Doug Brake, Alexandra Bruer  |  Research  |  Information Technology & Innovation Foundation

Open Radio Access Networks (Open RANs) would define open standards and interfaces between components of wireless RANs, providing a unique opportunity to diversify the supply chain by separating today’s integrated, single-provider RAN systems into modular parts. This report by the Information Technology & Innovation Foundation provides the history of Open RAN, the technology's benefits and challenges, and recommendations for policymakers. The key takeaways are:

  • Open RAN is a concept that encourages interoperable interfaces among various RAN components (the distributed unit, centralized unit, radio unit, etc.), so a range of vendors can provide components for different parts of the network.
  • Open RAN will help telecommunications providers tackle market challenges such as a lack of supplier diversity, a reliance on one specific vendor, and the black-box nature of RAN hardware.
  • Open RAN offers an important component of a potential solution that counters growing security concerns associated with Chinese telecom equipment maker Huawei.
  • Many questions remain unanswered as Open RAN begins to enter the wireless market. Until answers are clear and unchallenged, policymakers should remain skeptical of throwing all resources toward Open RAN deployment.
  • To support the future of Open RAN, the United States needs to support an effective transition to an open and disaggregated wireless infrastructure with continued investment and innovation—not market interference to force a premature transition.

Satellite

FCC Authorizes Boeing Broadband Satellite Constellation

Press Release  |  Press release

The Federal Communications Commission approved an application from Boeing for a license to construct, deploy, and operate a satellite constellation. As detailed in its FCC application, Boeing plans to provide
broadband and communications services for residential, commercial, institutional, governmental, and professional users in the United States and globally. The FCC's Order approves Boeing’s application for a non-geostationary orbit fixed-satellite service system using frequencies in portions of the V-band, and to operate inter-satellite links (ISLs) using frequencies in portions of the V-band. It also dismisses Boeing’s request to operate ISLs in certain frequency bands that are not allocated internationally for operations of the FSS in the space-to-space direction in the ITU Radio Regulations. Boeing’s plan involves placing 132 satellites into low Earth orbit at an altitude of 1,056 kilometers (about 656 miles). Another 15 will be launched to “non-geostationary orbit” at an altitude between 27,355 and 44,221 km (16,998 to 27,478 miles). The company has six years to launch half of its satellite constellation and nine years to deploy the entire network.

The latest space race is all about improving Internet access

Chris Velazco  |  Washington Post

Whether you knew it or not, the new space race that’s unfolding is about Internet access. Since 2019, Elon Musk’s SpaceX has put more than 1,000 of its Starlink satellites into low-earth orbit as part of a plan to provide broadband Internet to underserved communities around the world. And just this week, Amazon announced that it plans to put its first prototype Project Kuiper satellites in orbit by the end of 2022 with a similar goal in mind. These companies are trying to go after an estimated 4 billion people without access to the Internet as well as businesses that operate in remote areas such as airlines and cruise ships. As lawmakers work out how to extend broadband Internet to parts of the country that need it most, a new generation of satellites may be able to help keep some families in rural areas connected and their kids educated — for a price. Here’s what you need to know about how these new Internet services work and how they stack up against each other.

BT and OneWeb fire up new LEO satellite connectivity deal

Bevin Fletcher  |  Fierce

BT Group and low-earth orbit (LEO) satellite venture OneWeb are taking an earlier agreement to new heights. The partners signed a deal for connectivity services and expect to fire up the first live trials in early 2022. The global distribution partner agreement announced builds on a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) the partners reached in July. Both companies are headquartered in Britain and BT plans to start with lab tests in its Bristol facility to show how LEO satellite services integrate with existing terrestrial capabilities. It aims for live trials to follow early in 2022, and BT said the deal marks a clear roadmap toward initial satellite services becoming available to customers within a year. OneWeb is still building its LEO constellation and expects to reach global coverage by mid-2022 with 648 satellites. With its current constellation and capacity, BT said early trials will focus on using OneWeb as a supplement for backhaul, providing low latency to sites where the operator needs additional capacity or for added resiliency as a backup solution. Tapping satellites for IoT backhaul and for fixed wireless access to serve rural areas could also come into play once OneWeb increases its own capacity, according to BT.

Privacy

House Commerce Republicans Unveil Strategy to Establish a National Privacy Standard

The House Energy and Commerce Committee's Republicans announced a comprehensive legislative draft that establishes a national privacy standard to protect Americans and sets clear rules for consumer privacy and data security in the US. Every Member on the Consumer Protection and Commerce Subcommittee will lead on framework solutions in this comprehensive package, which is guided by Republican Leader Cathy McMorris Rodgers' (R-WA) four privacy principles to ensure a national standard that promotes innovation, protects consumers and sets clear rules for data privacy in America.  Similar to Senate Commerce Republicans’ privacy bill, the SAFE DATA Act, this new draft bill would not let private citizens sue over violations and would not allow state laws to exceed the “one national standard.” The Republicans are also calling for the creation of a Bureau of Consumer Privacy and Data Security — something that Democrats on the committee have proposed devoting money to as part of their partisan social spending package. Another section of the draft bill includes a legislative fix for the FTC’s section 13(b) authority, which the Supreme Court gutted earlier in 2021. It would also give the FTC the authority to fine big tech companies that misuse data up to $100,000 per violation on their first offense.

Security

FCC Terminates China Telecom Services in the US

Press Release  |  Federal Communications Commission

The Federal Communications Commission adopted an order ending China Telecom (Americas) Corporation’s ability to provide domestic interstate and international telecommunications services within the United States. The Order on Revocation and Termination directs China Telecom Americas to discontinue any domestic or international services that it provides pursuant to its section 214 authority within sixty days following the release of the order. Promoting national security is an integral part of the FCC’s responsibility to advance the public interest, and this action carries out that mission to safeguard the nation’s telecommunications infrastructure from potential security threats. Based in part on the recommendation of the Executive Branch agencies, the FCC found that China Telecom Americas failed to rebut the serious concerns of the Executive Branch about its continued presence in the United States. The FCC will issue a consumer guide after the Order is released that explains this action and what other options consumers might consider for mobile services.

Devices

The free laptop program built into President Biden's reconciliation plan

Makena Kelly  |  Vox

The bipartisan infrastructure bill contains billions to expand high-speed broadband across the country, aiming to close the digital divide over the next 10 years. But the Biden administration’s $65 billion down payment on broadband can only help connect families who can afford a computer. So President Biden’s latest version of the Build Back Better program goes further, allocating new funds to bring federally funded desktops, laptops, and tablets to low-income Americans. The Connected Device Grant Program would help provide free or discounted desktops, laptops, or tablets to low-income households. To accomplish that goal, the Commerce Department would receive $475 million to award community groups that want to distribute these devices locally. The device program has been championed by Sen Raphael Warnock (D-GA) and Rep A Donald McEachin (D-VA), whose Device Access for Every American Act was roped into the Build Back Better budget reconciliation package and amended into the nearly half a billion grant program currently authorized under the measure. Funding the program through the grant model leaves the specifics of implementation up to local groups, which could include anything from housing authorities to local libraries. Experts also expect the private sector to play a significant role in distributing devices once the grant funding is approved by Congress. Hoping to stretch the grant dollars further, community groups could partner with device manufacturers to buy devices in bulk or offer them at a discounted rate.

Climate

Help Make the Planet Greener by Getting Online

Martha Escutia, Sunne Wright McPeak  |  Op-Ed  |  Broadband Breakfast

On November 1, President Biden joined world leaders at the United Nations Climate Change Conference of the Parties, or COP26, in Glasgow, Scotland. Broadband also is a “green strategy” that can help lessen impacts on the environment and reduce greenhouse gas emissions and is a key linchpin, as is housing, for a triple bottom-line strategy to promote sustainability: prosperous economy, quality environment, and community equity. A 2021 State Survey on Broadband Adoption by the California Emerging Technology Fund in partnership with the University of Southern California shows post-pandemic, most employed respondents said they expected to continue with a reduced or no commute. The survey showed that this pattern of telecommuting could reduce 55 percent of vehicle trips relative to pre-pandemic levels. Lack of affordable broadband, however, is an impediment for far too many Californians do not have high-speed internet connectivity at home. These findings call out the need for strategic planning and investments. Major new state and federal spending initiatives designed to speed progress, mega-projects such as modernizing power grids and building middle-mile internet connections will not happen overnight. Smarter, future-proofed planning now calls for deploying the most efficient networks, affordable home internet programs, forward-thinking government-private sector collaborations and an evolving willingness by corporations to take on stewardship of environmental and other societal challenges. We must be in this together. If we ignore broadband as a key factor in maintaining environmental, social and economic progress in California and beyond, we do so at the peril of ourselves and our next generations.

[Martha Escutia is vice president of Government Relations and Special Counsel at the University of Southern California and a founding member of the board of the California Emerging Technology Fund. Sunne Wright McPeak is President and CEO of California Emerging Technology Fund.]

Policymakers

Senate Commerce Committee plans quick turnaround for FCC nominees

Benjamin Din  |  Politico

The Senate Commerce Committee is planning to pull together a wide-ranging confirmation hearing for the week of November 15 to hear from a bevy of President Joe Biden’s telecommunications nominees. The Federal Communications Commission nominees are Chair Jessica Rosenworcel, who’s up for another term, and new commissioner pick Gigi Sohn. As Politico previously reported, Sohn may face a tougher time given the Senate’s 50-50 split and uncertainty about where certain moderate Democrats like Sen Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) may fall. Sinema is a member of Senate Commerce, so this hearing could offer clues about how she’s leaning. Sen Maria Cantwell (D-WA) said the hearing’s precise date and the slate of nominees to be considered are still in flux. The other nominees in the mix would be Alan Davidson, Biden’s pick for the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, and Alvaro Bedoya, his nominee to fill out the Federal Trade Commission. Although nominees typically try to meet individually with senators, this session will be the highest-profile public opportunity for members to pepper them with questions, from how they will approach interagency airwave debates to what types of broadband and media regulation they will seek. If the nominees are confirmed, they’d create tie-breaking Democratic majorities on the FCC and FTC.

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Grace Tepper (grace AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2021. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
1041 Ridge Rd, Unit 214
Wilmette, IL 60091
847-328-3040
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2021