Daily Digest 10/18/2019 (Zuckerberg and Free Speech)

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
Table of Contents

Broadband

Commissioner Starks Remarks to SHLB Conference  |  Read below  |  FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission
Connecting Communities with High-Performance Broadband  |  Read below  |  Jonathan Sallet  |  Speech  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society
The Case for Fiber to the Home, Today: Why Fiber is a Superior Medium for 21st Century Broadband  |  Read below  |  Bennett Cyphers  |  Research  |  Electronic Frontier Foundation
Video: Broadband Struggles in Greater Minnesota  |  Public Broadcasting System

Wireless

Sen. Kennedy: FCC Should Hold Public Auction of C-Band  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News
FCC's Pai to Hill: As of Friday, TV Repack Should Be Over 66% Complete  |  Broadcasting&Cable
The $50 Billion 5G Battle: The Wireless Industry Needs More Airwaves, But It’s Going to Be Costly  |  Read below  |  Aaron Pressman  |  Fortune
Civil Rights Groups Strike Diversity Agreement with T-Mobile-Sprint  |  Read below  |  John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News
Commissioner Starks on Diversity MOU  |  Read below  |  FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks  |  Press Release  |  Federal Communications Commission
Sen Klobuchar Statement on Federal Communications Commission Approval of T-Mobile/Sprint Merger  |  US Senate
Report Finds Sparse 5G Coverage with AT&T and Verizon Offering the Fastest Speeds, but Sprint Has Broader Reach  |  telecompetitor

Platforms

Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg Defends Free Speech Amid Calls for Tighter Controls  |  Read below  |  Ryan Tracy  |  Wall Street Journal, New York Times, USA Today
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg says in interview he fears ‘erosion of truth’ but defends allowing politicians to lie in ads  |  Washington Post
Mark Zuckerberg op-ed: Facebook Stands for Free Expression  |  Wall Street Journal
On Facebook’s live stream, Zuckerberg’s free-speech lecture got a big thumbs up  |  Washington Post
Martin Luther King Jr.'s daughter knocks Zuckerberg for invoking her father while defending Facebook  |  Hill, The
Biden campaign slams Zuckerberg's 'feigned concern for free expression'  |  Hill, The
'Time' Owner Benioff: Sec. 230 Needs to Go  |  Multichannel News

Privacy

Sen Wyden Introduces Comprehensive Bill to Secure Americans’ Personal Information and Hold Corporations Accountable  |  Read below  |  Sen Ron Wyden (D-OR)  |  Press Release  |  US Senate
FTC Extends Deadline for Comments on COPPA Rule until December 9  |  Federal Trade Commission
Who Should Enforce Privacy Protections?  |  Read below  |  Claire Park  |  New America

Security

Chairman Pai warns about China's 'leverage' over NBA: Imagine what Beijing can do with 5G networks  |  Read below  |  Joshua Nelson  |  Fox News
Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Wicker Releases Investigation Report on CPSC Data Breaches  |  Senate Commerce Committee

Elections

FCC resolves complaints against 11 commercial TV stations and clarifies its political file disclosure rules  |  Federal Communications Commission
Unpacking the Political Ad Battle Between Elizabeth Warren and Mark Zuckerberg  |  Public Knowledge
Sen Elizabeth Warren raised 5 times as much money from Big Tech as Joe Biden did  |  Vox
Corporations Are Limiting Public Access to Presidential Primary Debates  |  Vice

Policymakers

37th Annual Parker Lecture Honorees Underscore the Importance of “Remembering Our Stories”  |  Read below  |  Cheryl Leanza  |  Press Release  |  United Church of Christ’s Office of Communication

Stories From Abroad

France accuses Google of flouting EU copyright law meant to help news publishers  |  Los Angeles Times
Today's Top Stories

Broadband

Commissioner Starks Remarks to SHLB Conference

FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks  |  Speech  |  Federal Communications Commission

When you visit today’s libraries, they are a long ways from the Dewey decimal system. I have observed at least four ways that libraries today are serving Americans in exciting new ways as 21st Century Community Tech Hubs, and are “meeting people where they are.” First, libraries are providing internet access to Americans who otherwise lack it—they are lending their Wi-Fi signals and, in some cases, are lending connectivity itself. Lending hot spots provides a connection when the internet is available in neighborhoods, but not at an affordable rate. This is a key problem and I appreciate this innovative approach that libraries are taking to address it. Second, libraries still serve an indispensable role in communities as a place to learn, offering reading and literacy programs geared toward very young children, for teens, and for adults. In addition, libraries also provide essential information to newly-arrived refugees who are working to establish a place for themselves and their families in the US. Third, I have seen how libraries play a critical role in getting people back on their feet – assisting those particularly looking to secure employment. This is an important trend and it’s not an exception or a corner case—libraries are providing these types of resources throughout the country. 73% of public libraries provide help with job applications and interviewing skills. 68% have programs to help library customers use electronic search tools to find job openings, and over a third of libraries offer workspaces for mobile workers. And finally, libraries also play a stabilizing role as “2nd Responders” in communities in the wake of disaster and disruption.

Connecting Communities with High-Performance Broadband

Jonathan Sallet  |  Speech  |  Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Based on what we’ve learned, we’ve formulated three basic broadband principles for community anchor institution policy.

  • First, community anchor institutions need access to competitively-priced, High-Performance Broadband, and they deserve the discretion to make informed choices about what best serves their communities.
  • Second, broadband is needed to connect community anchor institutions with their users wherever they may be.
  • Third, community anchor institutions can serve as launching pads for communitywide broadband access and, in places where broadband has already been deployed, more broadband competition.

So, how do we support these principles? Let me review some of our recommendations...

[Jonathan Sallet is a Benton Senior Fellow. He works to promote broadband access and deployment, to advance competition, including through antitrust, and to preserve and protect internet openness.]

The Case for Fiber to the Home, Today: Why Fiber is a Superior Medium for 21st Century Broadband

Bennett Cyphers  |  Research  |  Electronic Frontier Foundation

We are in dire need of universal fiber plans. Major telecom carriers such as AT&T and Verizon have discontinued their fiber-to-the-home efforts, leaving most people facing expensive cable monopolies for the future. While much of the Internet infrastructure has already transitioned to fiber, a supermajority of households and businesses across the country still have slow and outdated connections. Transitioning the “last mile” into fiber will require a massive effort from industry and government—an effort the rest of the world has already started. Unfortunately, arguments by the U.S. telecommunications industry that 5G or currently existing DOCSIS cable infrastructure are more than up to the task of substituting for fiber have confused lawmakers, reporters, and regulators into believing we do not have a problem. In response, EFF has recently completed extensive research into the currently existing options for last mile broadband and lays out what the objective technical facts demonstrate. By every measurement, fiber connections to homes and businesses are, by far, the superior choice for the 21st century. It is not even close.

Wireless

Sen. Kennedy: FCC Should Hold Public Auction of C-Band

John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News

Senate Financial Services Subcommittee Chairman John Kennedy (R-LA) lit into Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai for even considering private spectrum deals with foreign owned satellite companies, which say they can free up C-Band spectrum for 5G faster than an FCC auction. Chairman Kennedy told Chairman Pai that his mind could be changed, but he was currently biased for a public auction so that the American taxpayer, not "Luxembourg" (where some of the satellite operators are based) should reap the profits from repurposing some of the band for 5G. He pointed out that the C-Band auction could generate up to $60 billion and what it could buy if it went to the Treasury rather than Luxembourg. As to the legality, Chairman Pai said FCC lawyers were looking into that. Pai told the subcommittee that the FCC favored a market-based approach, but that meant flexibility rather than top-down government mandates, suggesting it definitely did not necessarily favoring private deals over public auctions. In fact, he pointed out that the FCC had held some 93 spectrum auctions in the past 25 years. 

The $50 Billion 5G Battle: The Wireless Industry Needs More Airwaves, But It’s Going to Be Costly

Aaron Pressman  |  Fortune

As the big wireless companies roll out super-fast 5G technology, they're facing a significant crunch in airwave spectrum to cover the whole country. There's a possible swath of airwaves that they're eying to solve the problem, but other communications industry players don't want to surrender the space easily. The years-long battle, which is now playing out at the Federal Communications Commission, pits some of the most powerful players in Washington, D.C. on opposite sides. And it's coming to a head with a final decision due in the next few months. The fight is over a segment of airwaves from 3.7 GHz to 4.2 GHz known as the C-band, which seems perfect for 5G usage. The frequency is low enough to travel long distances and penetrate buildings but also offers enough bandwidth for super-speedy downloads. Analysts say the major wireless companies would pay $30 billion to $50 billion for the rights to use a significant part of the C-band for 5G.

Civil Rights Groups Strike Diversity Agreement with T-Mobile-Sprint

John Eggerton  |  Multichannel News

A number of civil rights groups have struck an agreement with T-Mobile-Sprint to expand on the companies' diversity initiatives significantly if the two close on their merger. Those include expanding wireless to low income communities and a "significant philanthropic investment." According to the groups, a memorandum of understanding (MOU) has been filed with the FCC along those lines, which include initiatives to improve diversity in the areas of Corporate Governance; Workforce Recruitment and Retention; Procurement and Entrepreneurship; Wireless Services (including 5G Wireless Services) for Low Income Consumers; and Philanthropy and Community Investment. 

Commissioner Starks on Diversity MOU

FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks  |  Press Release  |  Federal Communications Commission

Our major companies should have a workforce that looks like America, from entry-level positions to the board of directors. As I have long advocated, diversity is more than just best practices – it is good business. I appreciate how this principle is reflected in the recent Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between T-Mobile and the National Urban League, National Action Network, Asian Americans Advancing Justice-AAJC, OCA–Asian Pacific American Advocates, the League of United Latin American Citizens, and UnidosUS. The MOU includes important diversity and inclusion initiatives, including increased efforts to hire and retain a diverse workforce, better diverse representation on the board, and improved outreach to communities of color. While this development does not change my opposition to the merger between T-Mobile and Sprint, I boldly applaud the spirit behind these commitments and the roadmap that the document offers for other companies seeking to inject greater diversity and inclusion into their operations. To that end, I would expect T-Mobile to honor the commitments made here regardless of the outcome of pending litigation regarding this transaction. T-Mobile should fully utilize the wisdom and expertise of the civil rights organizations consulted here today consistent with its stated desire to champion diversity and inclusion. Execution is everything, and I look forward to seeing how T-Mobile follows through on the commitments made in this MOU.

Platforms

Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg Defends Free Speech Amid Calls for Tighter Controls

Facebook Chief Executive Officer Mark Zuckerberg said he believes it is dangerous for people to focus more on their desired political outcomes than giving a range of voices the opportunity to be heard. He compared the current moment of political polarization to other periods of intense social change, including the civil-rights movement. “Some people believe that giving more people a voice is driving division rather than bringing people together,” he said. “I am here today because I believe we must continue to stand for free expression.”

Invoking Frederick Douglass, Martin Luther King Jr., the Vietnam War and the First Amendment, Mr. Zuckerberg said he saw this moment as one in which Facebook wanted to be on the proper side of history by espousing the Western ideal of free speech and democracy — rather than buckle to a politically charged environment, even if it meant being unpopular. He contrasted Facebook’s position with that of China, where Beijing controls and censors speech. “People having the power to express themselves at scale is a new kind of force in the world — a Fifth Estate alongside the other power structures of society,” he said.

“I don’t think most people want to live in a world where you can only post things that tech companies believe to be 100% true,” he said. “We think people should be able to see for themselves what politicians are saying.” Zuckerberg’s speech evoked political themes. He mentioned “Air Force moms,” church groups and small businesses that use the company’s products. He touted Facebook’s creation of an oversight board to weigh in on decisions about appropriate content. He also emphasized Facebook’s American roots, pointing out the company remains blocked in China because it hasn’t been willing to concede to regulations there: “If another nation’s platform set the rules, our discourse could be defined by a completely different set of values,” he said.

Privacy

Sen Wyden Introduces Comprehensive Bill to Secure Americans’ Personal Information and Hold Corporations Accountable

Sen Ron Wyden (D-OR)  |  Press Release  |  US Senate

Sen Ron Wyden (R-OR) introduced sweeping new privacy legislation, the Mind Your Own Business Act, to create the strongest-ever protections for Americans’ private data and to hold accountable the corporate executives responsible for abusing our information. Wyden’s bill contains the most comprehensive protections for Americans’ private data ever introduced, and goes further than Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). It would give American consumers an easy, one-click way to stop companies from selling or sharing their personal information, give consumers radical transparency into how corporations use and share their data, and impose harsh fines and even prison terms for executives at corporations that misuse Americans’ data and lie about those practices to the government. The Mind Your Own Business Act protects Americans’ privacy, allows consumers to control the sale and sharing of their data, gives the FTC the authority to be an effective cop on the beat, and will spur a new market for privacy-protecting services. The bill empowers the FTC to:

  1. Establish minimum privacy and cybersecurity standards.
  2. Issue steep fines (up to 4% of annual revenue), on the first offense for companies and 10-20 year criminal penalties for senior executives who knowingly lie to the FTC.
  3. Create a national Do Not Track system that lets consumers stop companies from tracking them on the web, selling or sharing their data, or targeting advertisements based on their personal information. Companies that wish to condition products and services on the sale or sharing of consumer data must offer another, similar privacy-friendly version of their product, for which they can charge a reasonable fee. This fee will be waived for low-income consumers who are eligible for the Federal Communication Commission’s Lifeline program.
  4. Give consumers a way to review the personal information a company has about them, learn with whom it has been shared or sold, and to challenge inaccuracies in it.
  5. Hire 175 more staff to police the largely unregulated market for private data.
  6. Require companies to assess the algorithms that process consumer data to examine their impact on accuracy, fairness, bias, discrimination, privacy and security.

Who Should Enforce Privacy Protections?

Claire Park  |  New America

The Federal Trade Commission’s $5 billion settlement with Facebook over the company’s deceptive privacy practices made a big splash, raising questions about the role the FTC should play in enforcing US privacy laws. While some observers criticized the FTC for not going far enough, others felt the record fine demonstrated the FTC’s willingness to set new precedents for punitive actions—and its unique ability to serve as the cop on the beat. But that isn’t the end of the conversation. As Congress drafts legislation to protect individuals’ privacy, it should also consider how it wants those privacy protections enforced. While the FTC has long safeguarded privacy through various federal laws on specific issues, such as children’s privacy and credit information—as well as its Section 5 authority over unfair and deceptive practices—legislators have other avenues for protecting privacy. Some of these possible enforcement mechanisms were discussed at a recent event hosted by New America’s Open Technology Institute. 

Security

Chairman Pai warns about China's 'leverage' over NBA: Imagine what Beijing can do with 5G networks

Joshua Nelson  |  Fox News

Amid the NBA-China controversy, Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai said that the situation is a “disturbing lesson” on Chinese government leverage. “If the Chinese government has such leverage over NBA stars and the league itself, that raises the question, how else can they can export their censorship, their anti-Democratic values, and ultimately their control when it comes to even more important things like our 5G networks, the wireless networks of the future?” Chairman Pai said. He also mentioned China pressuring Apple to remove the Taiwanese flag from its iPhone emoji list in Hong Kong. “Just imagine if we have 5G networks that power all of our industries that work for our military. What kind of leverage the Chinese government could exert over the operators here in the United States if they want information about how we’re doing business, how we live our lives,” Chairman Pai said. “That is a threat that I don’t think the American people are willing to live with and I am certainly not either as the head of the FCC,” he added.

Policymakers

37th Annual Parker Lecture Honorees Underscore the Importance of “Remembering Our Stories”

Cheryl Leanza  |  Press Release  |  United Church of Christ’s Office of Communication

Three media justice advocates stressed the importance of retelling stories—and telling them accurately—at the 37th Annual Everett C. Parker Ethics in Telecommunications Lecture and Awards Breakfast today in Washington, DC, sponsored by the United Church of Christ’s media justice ministry, the Office of Communication, Inc. Three media justice advocates stressed the importance of retelling stories—and telling them accurately—at the 37th Annual Everett C. Parker Ethics in Telecommunications Lecture and Awards Breakfast today in Washington, DC, sponsored by the United Church of Christ’s media justice ministry, the Office of Communication, Inc. The Rev. Julian DeShazier, senior pastor of University Church in Chicago and the Emmy Award-winning hip-hop artist J.Kwest, delivered the Parker Lecture address. Cayden Mak, executive director of 18 Million Rising, an online organization that builds community in the Asian American and Pacific Islander community, received the Everett C. Parker Award in recognition of his work in support of greater public access to affordable and open broadband technologies. Sarah Macharia, global coordinator of the Global Media Monitoring Project (GMMP), traveled from Kenya to accept the Donald H. McGannon Award on behalf of her organization. The McGannon award recognizes special contributions in advancing the role of women and persons of color in the media; the GMMP is the longest and largest longitudinal study of women in the media—both their presence and how they are covered—in the world. The project’s next study, conducted at five-year intervals, will take place in 2020 and is expected to involve volunteers in 130 companies.

 

Submit a Story

Benton (www.benton.org) provides the only free, reliable, and non-partisan daily digest that curates and distributes news related to universal broadband, while connecting communications, democracy, and public interest issues. Posted Monday through Friday, this service provides updates on important industry developments, policy issues, and other related news events. While the summaries are factually accurate, their sometimes informal tone may not always represent the tone of the original articles. Headlines are compiled by Kevin Taglang (headlines AT benton DOT org) and Robbie McBeath (rmcbeath AT benton DOT org) — we welcome your comments.


© Benton Institute for Broadband & Society 2019. Redistribution of this email publication — both internally and externally — is encouraged if it includes this message. For subscribe/unsubscribe info email: headlines AT benton DOT org


Kevin Taglang

Kevin Taglang
Executive Editor, Communications-related Headlines
Benton Institute
for Broadband & Society
727 Chicago Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
847-328-3049
headlines AT benton DOT org

Share this edition:

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

Benton Institute for Broadband & Society

The Benton Institute for Broadband & Society All Rights Reserved © 2019