Originally published: March 20, 2017
Last updated: March 20, 2017 - 3:40pm
[Commentary] I often run across the belief, expressed in print or in person, that Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act allows for bulk collection of information and that it offers no protections whatsoever for non-US persons. Both of these are urban legends; neither of them is factually correct. 702 does not allow collection of bulk data, and 702 does not allow indiscriminate collection of non-US-person communication.
As I testified to Congress, it’s my belief, based on my personal experience and professional judgment, that Congress drew the balance of authority and restrictions in the right place when it enacted FAA 702 in 2008 and when it reauthorized it in 2012. This year provides an important opportunity to FISA Amendments Act to be carefully scrutinized once again. But as Congress continues its work, it’s worth remembering that things that aren’t broke don’t need fixing. Sometimes they just need to be extended as-is.
[April Doss is a partner and chair of the Cybersecurity and Privacy practice group at Saul Ewing. Prior to that, she spent over a decade at the National Security Agency, where she was the Associate General Counsel for Intelligence Law. ]
- NSA reform panel: Foreigners actually have privacy rights, too!
- Attorney General Holder: ‘We’re not done’ on NSA reform
- S. 1123 USA FREEDOM Act
- Privacy, Civil Liberties and the NSA
- NSA performed warrantless searches on Americans' calls and emails -- Clapper
- USA Freedom Act of 2015 (was H.R. 2048)
- CDT Submits Comments to the President’s Review Group on Surveillance Reform
- The great escape: How the NSA is driving companies out of US clouds
- Technologists’ Submit Comments to the NSA Review Group
- 2017 Intelligence Bill Would Constrain Privacy Board
- S. 1035 To extend authority relating to roving surveillance, access to business records, and individual terrorists as agents of foreign powers
- Judge: Warrantless Bulk Surveillance Is Legal
- New privacy bill aims at reforming FISA and the Patriot Act
- What Just Happened to NSA Reform?
- Technology Industry Responds to Surveillance Plan